Letters of Credit (L/C): Banks' Documentary Examination under UCP 600 Article 5
Banks Deal with Documents, Not Goods
“Banks deal with documents, not goods” is a practical expression of the fundamental documentary-credit principle that banks examine documents presented under a Letter of Credit rather than the goods, services, or actual performance to which those documents relate.
Banks examine a Commercial Invoice, Packing List, B/L, insurance document, Certificate of Origin, Inspection Certificate, and other required documents for documentary compliance with the credit, UCP 600, and applicable banking practice.
They do not normally inspect whether the actual goods meet the contractual quality, whether the physical quantity is correct, whether the cargo has been damaged, whether the goods are genuine, or whether they satisfy the buyer’s technical requirements.
This distinction is reflected in UCP 600 Article 5, under which banks deal with documents and not with the goods, services, or performance to which the documents may relate.
Goods may fully comply with the sales contract while the presentation is discrepant. Conversely, the presented documents may comply with the credit even though the actual goods are defective, short, counterfeit, or otherwise non-conforming.
Scope of This Article
| Item | Covered in This Article | Covered in Other Articles |
|---|---|---|
| UCP 600 Article 5 | The principle that banks examine documents rather than the goods | The complete UCP 600 framework and documentary-credit law are addressed separately. |
| Bank document examination | The basic scope of examination of presented documents | Internal procedures of individual banks must be confirmed with the relevant bank. |
| Discrepancies | Typical documentary problems even where the cargo is correct | Refusal notices, Waiver, and re-presentation are addressed in the discrepancy article. |
| B/L particulars | Shipment date, On Board Notation, Consignee, Notify Party, and similar entries | The legal nature, reverse-side terms, and cargo release are addressed in B/L articles. |
| Freight forwarders and NVOCCs | The relationship between L/C terms and accurate B/L preparation | NVOCC liability and limitation are addressed separately. |
| Cargo inspection | Controls for quality and quantity that bank examination cannot provide | Inspection appointment and inspection contracts are addressed separately. |
| Insurance documents | The distinction between bank acceptance and cargo-claim adjustment | Amount, endorsement, date, and other documentary checks are addressed in Insurance Documents Checked by Banks. |
| Marine cargo insurance | The different functions of documentary examination and cargo-loss cover | Coverage, exclusions, and cargo claims are addressed in cargo-insurance articles. |
| Export credit insurance | The distinction from protection against non-payment | Commercial risk, political risk, and insured-event requirements are addressed separately. |
Purpose and Background
Under a documentary credit, an issuing bank issues a credit at the request of the Applicant. Where the Beneficiary presents documents complying with the credit, the relevant bank processes payment, acceptance, or negotiation in accordance with its undertaking.
If banks were required to examine cargo quality, quantity, performance, production, packing, and contractual performance, they would need to conduct physical inspections and technical assessments for transactions throughout the world.
Documentary credits could not then operate as a prompt and standardised method of international settlement.
The system therefore separates documentary examination from the underlying sale and physical performance. Banks examine documents, while sellers, buyers, inspection companies, carriers, and insurers deal with the goods, performance, and related claims.
Basic Principle of UCP 600 Article 5
UCP 600 Article 5 limits the subject of bank examination to documents.
The principle means that a bank does not guarantee the existence, quality, quantity, value, performance, packing, or contractual conformity of the physical goods.
| Document | What the Bank Examines | What the Bank Normally Does Not Examine | Main Party Responsible |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commercial Invoice | Goods description, amount, currency, and issuer required by the credit | Whether the goods actually have the stated value or quality | Exporter, importer, and inspection company |
| B/L | Shipment notation, date, ports, shipper, consignee, and signature | The actual internal condition of the containerised cargo | Shipping line, NVOCC, and freight forwarder |
| Packing List | Stated packing, quantity, weight, marks, and numbers | Whether the packing is physically sufficient for transport | Exporter, packer, and inspection company |
| Insurance Document | Document type, amount, conditions, date, issuer, and endorsement | Whether a later cargo claim will be paid | Insurer or insurance agent |
| Certificate of Origin | Required issuer, form, and particulars | Whether the goods actually satisfy the applicable origin rule | Exporter, producer, issuing body, and customs authority |
| Inspection Certificate | Whether the required inspection document has been presented | An independent reinspection by the bank | Designated inspection company |
Bank Examination and Physical Cargo Verification
| Item | Bank Document Examination | Physical Cargo Verification | Main Party | Response to a Problem |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Determines whether a presentation complies with the credit. | Determines whether the goods comply with the sale. | Bank and sales parties or inspector | Separate the discrepancy from the cargo claim. |
| Subject | Presented documents | Goods, specifications, quality, quantity, and performance | Bank and importer or inspector | Arrange third-party inspection where appropriate. |
| Standard | L/C, UCP 600, ISBP, and documentary particulars | Sales contract, specifications, sample, and inspection standard | Bank and sales parties | Use clear warranties and inspection clauses. |
| Typical problem | Date, name, signature, amount, port, or original-count discrepancy | Defect, shortage, counterfeit goods, or insufficient performance | Bank and seller, buyer, or carrier | Identify the correct party against which to claim. |
| Conclusion | Complying presentation or discrepancy | Conforming or non-conforming goods | Bank and sales parties | Handle bank processing and the sales dispute separately. |
Main Documents Examined by Banks
| Document | Main Documentary Review | Typical Discrepancy | Physical Fact Not Verified by the Bank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commercial Invoice | Issuer, goods description, amount, currency, and credit reference | Excess amount, inconsistent description, or missing signature | Actual market value and quality |
| Packing List | Packing, quantity, weight, marks, and numbers | Inconsistent quantity, weight, or packing description | Strength of the physical packing and internal cargo condition |
| Bill of Lading | On Board Date, vessel, ports, Consignee, Notify Party, and signature | Late shipment, incorrect port, or incorrect consignee | Quality, quantity, and internal container condition |
| Insurance Policy or Certificate | Type, amount, coverage, currency, date, and endorsement | Insufficient amount, missing coverage, or defective endorsement | Cause of casualty and ultimate claim payment |
| Certificate of Origin | Issuer, country of origin, goods, and authentication | Incorrect issuer, origin, or Invoice number | Actual materials and manufacturing process |
| Inspection Certificate | Required issuer, inspection item, and result wording | Incorrect issuer, timing, or certificate wording | A second physical inspection by the bank |
| Other Certificate | Required issuer, form, wording, and signature | Incorrect title, issuer, signature, or statement | An independent investigation of the certified fact |
Main Situations in Which the Principle Applies
| Stage | What the Bank Does | What the Bank Does Not Do | Practical Response |
|---|---|---|---|
| L/C issuance | Issues the credit based on the Applicant’s instruction. | Does not guarantee the seller’s manufacturing ability or product quality. | The buyer should conduct seller due diligence and use contractual controls. |
| Presentation | Compares the documents with the credit. | Does not inspect the cargo at a warehouse or port. | The exporter should review the full presentation before submission. |
| B/L examination | Reviews shipment notation, dates, ports, and signature. | Does not verify the actual loading operation or cargo condition. | The forwarder should issue an accurate document reflecting the facts. |
| Insurance-document examination | Determines whether the required insurance document has been presented. | Does not guarantee payment of a future cargo claim. | Insurance coverage should be reviewed separately with the insurer. |
| Inspection-certificate examination | Determines whether the required certificate is presented. | Does not reperform the inspection. | The buyer should specify the inspector, timing, and method. |
| Payment or negotiation | Processes a complying presentation under the credit undertaking. | Does not adjudicate an underlying cargo-quality dispute. | The sales claim should be pursued under the sales contract. |
Problems Not Resolved by This Principle
| Problem | Why Bank Examination Does Not Resolve It | Main Party to Consult | Control |
|---|---|---|---|
| Defective quality | Documentary description and physical quality are different matters. | Seller, inspector, and technical personnel | Use specifications, inspection, and warranties. |
| Short quantity | The actual quantity may be short even where the documents state the required amount. | Seller, carrier, and inspection company | Preserve loading and discharge evidence. |
| Counterfeit goods | The bank does not authenticate the physical merchandise. | Manufacturer, rights holder, and inspection company | Use authenticity certificates and inspection. |
| Transit damage | Goods may be damaged even where the documents comply. | Carrier, insurer, and surveyor | Use cargo insurance, casualty notice, and Claim Letter. |
| Sales-contract breach | The bank is not an adjudicator of contractual performance. | Sales parties, lawyer, or arbitral tribunal | Review contractual remedies. |
| Buyer non-payment | Credit risk remains in transactions without effective bank protection. | Credit personnel, bank, and credit insurer | Use guarantees, advance payment, or credit insurance. |
| Sanctions or fraud | Legal and compliance issues are separate from ordinary documentary compliance. | Bank, legal personnel, and authority | Conduct separate sanctions and AML review. |
What Is a Discrepancy?
A discrepancy is an inconsistency between the presented documents and the terms of the credit or applicable documentary-credit practice.
Even where the goods comply with the sales contract, a discrepancy may arise from the B/L date, description, quantity, port, consignee, insurance condition, signature, or number of originals.
| Example | Documentary Problem | Physical Cargo Position | Possible Banking Result | Prevention |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Late shipment | Latest Shipment Date is May 31, while the On Board Date is June 1. | The cargo was shipped without physical problem. | The presentation may be treated as late shipment. | Control the shipment schedule and document date. |
| Incorrect Consignee | The L/C requires a bank name, but the importer is named directly. | The cargo is intended for the correct importer. | The B/L may be discrepant. | Reflect the L/C in the Shipping Instruction. |
| Incorrect Notify Party | The notified party differs from the credit. | The destination party knows that the cargo has arrived. | The presentation may still be discrepant. | Review the draft B/L before issue. |
| Missing On Board Notation | The required shipped-on-board statement or date is absent. | The cargo was physically loaded. | The On Board B/L requirement may not be met. | Request accurate notation from the carrier or NVOCC. |
| Missing Insurance Condition | War or Strikes wording required by the credit is absent. | The cargo may arrive without loss. | The insurance document may be discrepant. | Provide the L/C wording to the insurer in advance. |
| Incorrect Certificate Issuer | A certificate was issued by a party not specified in the credit. | The certified statement may nevertheless be factually correct. | The document may fail the required-document condition. | Confirm the issuer before shipment. |
| Late presentation | The documents are presented after the presentation period. | The cargo was shipped within the shipment period. | The documents may be treated as stale. | Calculate document collection and presentation deadlines. |
Correct Goods but Documentary Payment Problem
Even where the goods comply fully with the sale and the buyer wishes to receive them, the bank may treat the presentation as discrepant if the documents do not comply with the credit.
The exporter may need to arrange correction, reissue, re-presentation, an L/C Amendment, or an Applicant Waiver.
The exporter should not assume that the buyer will necessarily waive the discrepancy. The buyer may use it in negotiations concerning price, delay, or another commercial issue.
Complying Documents but Defective Goods
Documents may comply with the credit while the goods are defective, short, counterfeit, or outside the contractual specification.
Even after payment under a complying presentation, the buyer may retain claims against the seller under the sales contract for repair, replacement, damages, or termination.
Transactions requiring strong quality assurance should therefore use specifications, samples, warranties, pre-shipment inspection, and independent inspection in addition to the L/C.
Exporter Review
| Stage | Review | Risk if Missed | Response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Receipt of L/C | Shipment date, presentation period, required documents, and wording | An impossible condition is discovered after shipment. | Request an Amendment before shipment. |
| Order and production | Description, specification, quantity, and inspection | The goods and documents are inconsistent. | Align the contract, Invoice, and production instruction. |
| Booking | Ports, shipment date, B/L type, and consignee entry | The B/L does not comply with the credit. | Provide the L/C requirements to the freight forwarder. |
| Insurance arrangement | Document type, amount, coverage, currency, and endorsement | The insurance document is discrepant. | Provide the credit wording to the insurer or insurance agent. |
| Document preparation | Consistency among the Invoice, Packing List, B/L, and certificates | Cross-document inconsistency arises. | Use a cross-document checklist. |
| Before presentation | Originals, number of copies, signatures, dates, and deadline | Time to correct the documents is lost. | Use a dual review before presentation. |
Importer Review
An importer should not assume that opening an L/C guarantees receipt of contract-compliant goods.
| Transaction or Goods | Main Risk | Control in Addition to the L/C | Timing |
|---|---|---|---|
| First transaction | Unknown seller capability and authenticity | Due diligence, sample, and independent inspection | Before contract and L/C issue |
| Used machinery | Age, operating condition, missing parts, and performance | Physical inspection, trial operation, and detailed photographs | Before shipment |
| Branded goods | Counterfeit, unauthorised distribution, and infringement | Authenticity and authorised-distributor evidence | Before contract and shipment |
| Food or pharmaceutical-related goods | Quality, hygiene, expiry, and regulatory compliance | Inspection certificate, temperature control, and regulatory review | Before production and shipment |
| Dangerous goods | Declaration, packing, labelling, and regulatory breach | SDS, dangerous-goods declaration, and specialist review | Before Booking |
| Specially manufactured goods | Failure to meet the agreed specification | Approved specification, witnessed inspection, and performance test | During production and before shipment |
Freight Forwarder and NVOCC Involvement
| Operation | Support or Review | Matters Not Normally Determined | Main Liability Risk | Practical Response |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shipping Instruction | Reviews B/L particulars supplied under the L/C. | Guaranteeing compliance of the entire presentation | Transcription error or missed instruction | Require the shipper to provide relevant L/C terms. |
| Draft B/L | Prepares vessel, ports, Shipper, Consignee, and Notify Party. | Determining cargo quality or sales-contract performance | Incorrect B/L particulars | Retain evidence of draft approval. |
| On Board Notation | States information based on actual shipment. | Creating a fictitious date to satisfy the credit | False date or inaccurate transport document | Align the notation with Actual Carrier information. |
| Cargo particulars | States description, quantity, and packing based on shipper information. | Guaranteeing contents through physical inspection | Involvement in false or inaccurate particulars | Reject requests for factually incorrect wording. |
| Presentation support | Issues, corrects, and delivers the B/L. | Guaranteeing bank acceptance | Correction delay, original control, and authority | Share deadlines and retain correction history. |
Limits When Aligning the B/L with the L/C
A freight forwarder or NVOCC may be asked to prepare the B/L in accordance with L/C requirements.
It must not, however, state an On Board Date, cargo description, quantity, port, vessel, or consignee relationship that differs from the actual shipment merely to avoid a discrepancy.
| Request | Problem | Proper Response | Party to Consult |
|---|---|---|---|
| Backdate the shipment date. | The date would differ from actual shipment. | State the actual date and consider an Amendment or Waiver. | Shipper, bank, and shipping line |
| Change the goods description to wording inconsistent with the cargo. | The B/L may misdescribe the goods. | Describe the goods accurately and amend the L/C or Invoice. | Shipper and bank |
| State ports different from the actual route. | The B/L would not reflect the transport. | State the actual ports and places. | Shipping line and shipper |
| Sign as Carrier without authority. | Signing capacity and authenticity are affected. | Use the correct capacity and agency statement. | NVOCC, shipping line, and legal personnel |
| Change quantity to match the Invoice. | The stated quantity may differ from the quantity received for carriage. | Review receipt records and state the accurate quantity. | Shipper, CFS, and terminal |
The proper response is to issue an accurate transport document reflecting the actual shipment and advise the shipper that an Amendment, Waiver, or other banking solution is required.
Relationship to Marine Cargo Insurance
Where the L/C requires an Insurance Policy or Insurance Certificate, the bank examines whether the insurance document complies with the credit.
Bank acceptance of the insurance document does not establish that a cargo claim will be paid. The insurer separately reviews the cause of loss, coverage, period, exclusion, amount of loss, evidence, and preservation of recovery rights.
| Item | L/C Insurance-Document Examination | Cargo-Claim Adjustment | Main Party |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Determines whether the insurance document complies with the credit. | Determines whether the casualty is payable. | Bank and insurer |
| Main documents | L/C, Insurance Policy, and Certificate | Policy, casualty evidence, and survey report | Bank and insurer or insurance agent |
| Main decision | Compliance or discrepancy | Coverage, exclusion, and amount of loss | Bank and insurer |
| Result | Documentary treatment under the L/C | Payment or denial of the insurance claim | Each must be reviewed separately. |
Relationship to Export Credit Insurance
Marine cargo insurance principally responds to physical loss of or damage to cargo in transit.
Export credit insurance addresses qualifying non-payment resulting from buyer insolvency, prolonged default, transfer restriction, or other covered commercial or political risks.
| System | Main Purpose | Main Risk | Typical Exclusion from Its Function | Review |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| L/C | Uses a bank undertaking based on documents. | Settlement against a complying presentation | Guarantee of the physical quality of goods | Review the issuing bank, confirmation, terms, and discrepancies. |
| Marine cargo insurance | Insures physical cargo loss in transit. | Breakage, wet damage, theft, and loss | Simple buyer non-payment | Review cover, transit, exclusions, and insurable interest. |
| Export credit insurance | Insures qualifying non-payment. | Buyer credit and covered political risks | Ordinary physical cargo damage | Review credit limit, insured event, and notice deadline. |
| Third-party inspection | Verifies cargo quality, quantity, or condition. | Specification, quantity, condition, and performance | Bank undertaking or insurance indemnity | Review inspector, timing, method, and standard. |
Application Flow
- Review the sales contract: Confirm goods, specifications, quantity, inspection, payment, and warranty.
- Review the L/C: Confirm required documents, shipment deadline, presentation period, and wording.
- Confirm feasibility: Ask each responsible party whether shipment and documents can meet the conditions.
- Request necessary Amendments: Correct impractical terms before shipment.
- Manage goods and documents separately: Control production and inspection as well as document preparation.
- Provide conditions to the freight forwarder: Supply accurate B/L requirements.
- Cross-check the documents: Compare the Invoice, Packing List, B/L, insurance document, and certificates.
- Reject false particulars: Do not create false information merely to comply with the L/C.
- Present within the deadline: Confirm originals, copies, signatures, and time limits.
- Handle cargo problems separately: Process quality, shortage, casualty, and sales claims through the appropriate procedures.
The central operational requirement is to maintain separate controls for documentary correctness and physical cargo conformity.
Cases Frequently Causing Practical Problems
| Case | Main Cause | Bank Examination | Cargo or Contract Issue | Initial Response |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The On Board Date is one day after the shipment deadline. | Shipment delay or poor schedule control | B/L date against Latest Shipment Date | No physical cargo defect | Review reissue, Amendment, or Waiver. |
| The Consignee differs from the L/C. | Failure to reflect the credit in the Shipping Instruction | B/L particulars against the credit | The goods are intended for the correct importer. | Correct the B/L while considering cargo-release effects. |
| The documents comply, but the goods are defective. | Seller non-performance or inadequate inspection | The presentation may be complying. | Quality defect and sales-contract breach | Prepare contractual and inspection evidence. |
| An inspection certificate exists, but quantity is short. | Limited inspection scope or shortage during handling | Presence and wording of the required certificate | Actual quantity and point of shortage | Notify the inspector and carrier. |
| The exporter asks the NVOCC to backdate the B/L. | Late shipment | Date appearing in the presented B/L | False or inaccurate transport document | Reject the request and discuss an Amendment. |
| The bank accepts the insurance document, but the insurer denies the claim. | The casualty is excluded or outside cover. | Documentary compliance with the L/C | Coverage under the insurance policy | Separate bank examination from claim adjustment. |
| The buyer uses a discrepancy to demand a discount. | Exporter document error | Existence of a discrepancy | A separate commercial negotiation | Review correction, Waiver, and payment obligations. |
| The documents comply, but sanctions review holds payment. | Bank compliance or sanctions review | A separate issue from ordinary compliance | Regulatory status of parties, banks, goods, or end use | Consult the bank and legal personnel. |
Example 1: Correct Cargo but Late On Board Date
Facts: The L/C stated May 31 as the Latest Shipment Date. The goods were manufactured to the buyer’s specification and shipped in sound condition, but the B/L showed an On Board Date of June 1.
Bank Examination: The bank reviews whether the date in the B/L complies with the credit rather than the quality of the cargo or the buyer’s willingness to receive it.
Physical Position: The cargo may be entirely satisfactory, but the document shows late shipment.
Response: The exporter did not request a false date. It asked the Applicant and issuing bank to consider a Waiver or Amendment.
Conclusion: Correct cargo does not cure a documentary late-shipment discrepancy.
Example 2: Complying Documents but Inoperative Used Machinery
Facts: An importer purchased used machinery under an L/C. The exporter presented a complying Invoice, B/L, and Inspection Certificate, and payment was processed. The machinery failed during testing after arrival.
Bank Examination: The bank examined the required documentary particulars but did not operate or technically test the machinery.
Physical Position: The dispute concerns performance warranties, inspection scope, and contractual conformity.
Response: The importer collected the sales contract, inspection report, specifications, photographs, and test records and pursued repair, replacement, or damages against the seller.
Conclusion: Payment under an L/C and physical conformity of the goods are separate matters.
Example 3: Request to Change the B/L Date
Facts: Actual shipment occurred after the L/C shipment deadline. The exporter asked the NVOCC to change the On Board Date to a date within the credit period.
Analysis: An NVOCC may assist in preparing a B/L that meets documentary requirements, but it must not state a shipment date inconsistent with the actual shipment.
Response: The NVOCC refused the request and issued the B/L with the actual date. It advised the exporter to seek an Amendment or Waiver.
Conclusion: Because banks rely on documents, the accuracy and authenticity of those documents must be protected.
When to Consult a Bank or Specialist
| Situation | Main Party to Consult | Issue | Reason for Urgency |
|---|---|---|---|
| The L/C requirement cannot be performed. | Advising or transaction bank | Amendment, alternative document, and deadline | Some conditions cannot be corrected after shipment. |
| A discrepancy is raised. | Presenting bank, issuing bank, and Applicant | Correction, re-presentation, Waiver, and refusal deadline | Presentation and expiry deadlines apply. |
| A false B/L is requested. | Shipping line, NVOCC, and legal personnel | Actual shipment, signing authority, and legal risk | There is a risk of involvement in document fraud. |
| Serious cargo fraud is discovered after a complying presentation. | Bank and sales-contract lawyer | Fraud, possible payment restraint, and contractual remedies | Fraud requires a different response from an ordinary quality dispute. |
| Cargo damage and a discrepancy occur together. | Bank, insurer, and freight forwarder | Presentation, insurance notice, Claim Letter, and evidence | Several deadlines must be managed simultaneously. |
Common Misunderstandings
| Misunderstanding | Actual Position | Practical Caution |
|---|---|---|
| An L/C guarantees cargo quality. | An L/C is principally a document-based payment mechanism. | Control quality through the contract, inspection, and warranties. |
| The bank must pay if the goods are correct. | The documents must comply with the credit. | Review the goods and documents separately. |
| The bank uses the B/L to determine that the cargo is sound. | The bank examines B/L particulars and not the interior of the container. | Confirm cargo condition through inspection and delivery records. |
| An Inspection Certificate means that the bank guarantees quality. | The bank determines whether the required certificate was presented. | Review the inspection scope under the inspection contract. |
| Bank acceptance of an insurance policy guarantees claim payment. | Claim payment depends on the insurer’s casualty review. | Separate documentary examination from insurance adjustment. |
| A discrepancy does not matter if the buyer wants the cargo. | A formal Waiver or another banking solution may still be required. | Do not rely solely on an oral acceptance. |
| The B/L date may be changed to comply with the L/C. | The B/L must reflect the actual shipment facts. | Use an Amendment or Waiver instead. |
| The freight forwarder guarantees the entire L/C presentation. | The forwarder mainly prepares or issues transport documents. | The exporter and bank must review the complete presentation. |
| Because banks examine only documents, false goods or documents are acceptable. | Fraud, false documents, and sanctions are separate serious issues. | Article 5 must not be treated as permission for misconduct. |
| A complying presentation ends every sales-contract dispute. | Quality, shortage, and non-conformity claims may remain after payment. | Review remedies under the sales contract. |
Decision Checklist
| Review Stage | Party to Consult | Items to Confirm | Action if a Problem Exists |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales-contract preparation | Exporter, importer, and legal personnel | Specification, quantity, inspection, warranty, and claim conditions | State matters not verified by banks in the sales contract. |
| Before L/C issue | Importer, issuing bank, and exporter | Required documents, issuer, wording, and deadlines | Correct impractical requirements. |
| Receipt of L/C | Exporter, advising bank, and trade personnel | Shipment date, presentation period, document type, and wording | Request an Amendment before shipment. |
| Booking | Exporter, freight forwarder, and NVOCC | B/L type, vessel, ports, Consignee, and Notify Party | Correct the Shipping Instruction. |
| Draft B/L | Exporter, freight forwarder, and NVOCC | On Board Notation, date, signing capacity, and cargo particulars | Correct the document according to the actual transport facts. |
| Insurance-document preparation | Insurer or insurance agent and exporter | Document type, amount, coverage, currency, date, and endorsement | Obtain a formally reissued document before presentation. |
| Third-party inspection | Importer, exporter, and inspection company | Inspector, subject, timing, method, and acceptance standard | State the inspection scope in the contract and L/C. |
| Before bank presentation | Exporter, trade personnel, and transaction bank | Cross-document consistency, originals, signatures, and deadlines | Correct inconsistencies before presentation. |
| Discrepancy | Presenting bank, issuing bank, and Applicant | Comment, correction, re-presentation, Waiver, and deadline | Select a formal banking response. |
| Cargo claim | Sales parties, inspector, carrier, and insurer | Quality, quantity, cause, risk allocation, and evidence | Handle the claim separately from the bank procedure. |
| Request for false particulars | Freight forwarder, shipping line, and legal personnel | Actual shipment facts and requested wording | Refuse the request and recommend an Amendment or other proper solution. |
Summary
“Banks deal with documents, not goods” expresses the UCP 600 Article 5 principle that banks examine presented documents rather than the goods, services, or actual contractual performance.
Banks examine whether an Invoice, Packing List, B/L, insurance document, Certificate of Origin, Inspection Certificate, or another document complies with the credit. They do not physically verify quality, quantity, performance, authenticity, or cargo damage.
Goods may be correct while the presentation is discrepant because of the B/L date, Consignee, Notify Party, On Board Notation, insurance condition, signature, or presentation deadline.
Conversely, documents may comply while the goods are defective, short, counterfeit, or outside specification. Those risks must be managed through the sales contract, technical specifications, independent inspection, sample approval, and warranties.
Freight forwarders and NVOCCs should understand the effect of B/L particulars on L/C settlement. They must not, however, state a false shipment date, cargo description, or transport fact merely to make the document appear compliant.
Bank acceptance of an insurance document is separate from payment of a cargo claim. Marine cargo insurance and export credit insurance also address different risks: physical cargo loss and qualifying non-payment.
Safe documentary-credit practice requires separate management of documents examined by banks, goods examined by the sales parties, cargo claims adjusted by insurers, and payment risks covered by credit controls or credit insurance.
