What Is a Confirmed L/C? Confirming Bank Undertaking and Practical Risks
What Is a Confirmed L/C? Confirming Bank Undertaking and Practical Risks
A Confirmed L/C is a documentary credit under which a bank other than the Issuing Bank adds its own undertaking, in addition to the undertaking of the Issuing Bank, to honour or negotiate a complying presentation.
It is also referred to as a Confirmed Letter of Credit or Confirmed Documentary Credit.
Under an ordinary L/C, the Beneficiary relies primarily on the undertaking of the Issuing Bank for payment.
Under a Confirmed L/C, the Confirming Bank adds a separate undertaking. Where a complying presentation is made, the Confirming Bank’s obligation does not depend solely on reimbursement from the Issuing Bank or on the Applicant’s ability to pay.
A Confirmed L/C may therefore be used where the exporter has concerns regarding the credit of the Issuing Bank, foreign-exchange shortages, transfer restrictions, or political and economic instability in the country of the Issuing Bank.
A Confirmed L/C is not, however, an unconditional payment guarantee.
The Confirming Bank’s undertaking depends on presentation of documents that comply with the terms of the credit, UCP 600, and international standard banking practice at the required bank, place, and time.
Payment may not proceed as expected where the presentation contains a Discrepancy, the presentation period has expired, the Confirming Bank has not extended its confirmation to an amendment, or payment is prohibited by applicable law or sanctions.
Scope of This Article
| Item | Covered in This Article | Covered in Other Articles |
|---|---|---|
| Definition of a Confirmed L/C | Structure under which a Confirming Bank adds an undertaking to that of the Issuing Bank | The basic L/C structure is covered in “What Is an L/C?” |
| UCP 600 | Confirmation practice under Articles 2, 7, 8, 9, 10, 14, 16, and 28 | The full UCP 600 framework is covered in the UCP 600 articles |
| Confirming Bank | Obligation to honour, accept, or negotiate a complying presentation | Internal credit limits and bank approval should be confirmed with the bank |
| Advising Bank | Difference between an Advising Bank and Confirming Bank | Detailed advising practice is covered in the Advising Bank articles |
| Issuing Bank risk | Protection against deterioration, suspension, or insolvency of the Issuing Bank | Bank credit ratings should be checked in financial information |
| Country risk | Foreign-exchange shortages, transfer restrictions, and political or economic conditions | Country-specific restrictions should be confirmed with the bank or export-credit insurer |
| Discrepancy | Why the Confirming Bank’s undertaking depends on a complying presentation | Individual discrepancies are covered in the L/C discrepancy articles |
| Amendments | Why confirmation does not automatically extend to every amendment | Detailed amendment practice is covered in the L/C Amendment articles |
| Silent Confirmation | Separate bank arrangement outside formal UCP 600 confirmation | Product-specific conditions must be confirmed with the providing bank |
| Stale B/L | Presentation period after shipment and expiry of the credit | B/L preparation requirements are covered in the B/L articles |
| Insurance documents | Compliance with UCP 600 Article 28 and the credit terms | Marine cargo insurance cover is addressed in the cargo insurance articles |
| Freight forwarder practice | Coordination of shipment dates, B/Ls, insurance documents, and presentation deadlines | The payment decision remains with the Confirming Bank or Issuing Bank |
Purpose and Background of Confirmation
An L/C replaces the buyer’s direct credit risk with the undertaking of the Issuing Bank.
Where the Issuing Bank is located in another country, the exporter must nevertheless consider not only the credit of that bank but also political conditions, availability of foreign currency, transfer restrictions, banking supervision, sanctions, and access to payment systems in that jurisdiction.
A Confirmed L/C adds the undertaking of another bank and thereby mitigates Issuing Bank risk and certain forms of country or transfer risk.
Where the Confirming Bank is located in the exporter’s country or another acceptable jurisdiction, the exporter may be able to claim payment or negotiation from that bank against a complying presentation rather than relying only on remittance from the Issuing Bank.
The Confirming Bank undertakes a documentary obligation.
It does not guarantee the quality, quantity, performance, value, contractual conformity, or commercial success of the goods.
Parties and Their Roles
| Party | Basic Role | Payment Obligation | Main Review Items | Practical Point |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Applicant | Buyer requesting issuance of the credit | Owes reimbursement obligations to the Issuing Bank | Credit terms, security, and allocation of charges | Applicant approval alone does not automatically cure a Discrepancy |
| Beneficiary | Exporter presenting documents under the credit | Does not pay but must make the required presentation | Credit terms, deadlines, and place for presentation | Confirm that confirmation was actually added |
| Issuing Bank | Issues the credit at the request of the Applicant | Undertakes under UCP 600 Article 7 against a complying presentation | Credit, jurisdiction, and payment terms | Its undertaking is separate from that of the Confirming Bank |
| Confirming Bank | Adds its undertaking upon the Issuing Bank’s authorisation or request | Undertakes under Article 8 against a complying presentation | Scope, availability, amendments, and expiry | A bank does not become a Confirming Bank merely by advising the credit |
| Advising Bank | Authenticates and advises the credit to the Beneficiary | Normally has no obligation to honour or negotiate unless it adds confirmation | Advice, apparent authenticity, and confirmation status | Receipt through a bank does not mean that the credit is confirmed |
| Nominated Bank | Bank with which the credit is available | Normally has no obligation unless it confirms or separately agrees to act | Available with, Available by, and place for presentation | Nomination must not be confused with confirmation |
| Reimbursing Bank | Handles bank-to-bank reimbursement | Acts under its reimbursement authorisation and applicable terms | Authorisation, currency, and payment route | Its role is separate from the Confirming Bank’s undertaking to the Beneficiary |
UCP 600 Framework
| UCP 600 Article | Main Rule | Relevance to a Confirmed L/C | Practical Review |
|---|---|---|---|
| Article 2 | Defines Confirmation, Confirming Bank, and Complying Presentation | Confirmation is an undertaking in addition to that of the Issuing Bank | Confirm that the bank and credit are correctly identified |
| Article 4 | A credit is separate from the underlying sale contract | A commercial dispute does not by itself extinguish the bank undertaking | Banks determine payment from the credit and presented documents |
| Article 5 | Banks deal with documents rather than goods, services, or performance | The Confirming Bank does not guarantee cargo quality | Use contractual inspection documents to manage quality risk |
| Article 7 | Establishes the undertaking of the Issuing Bank | The Issuing Bank has its own obligation against a complying presentation | Review the credit and jurisdiction of the Issuing Bank |
| Article 8 | Establishes the undertaking of the Confirming Bank | The Confirming Bank becomes bound when it adds its confirmation | Review the confirmation advice, availability, and presentation route |
| Article 9 | Governs advising of credits and amendments | An Advising Bank does not undertake payment unless it adds confirmation | Check for wording such as without adding confirmation |
| Article 10 | Governs amendments and the Confirming Bank’s treatment of amendments | The Confirming Bank may decline to extend confirmation to an amendment | Review confirmation separately for each amendment |
| Article 14 | Sets standards and timeframes for examination of documents | The Confirming Bank makes its own compliance determination | Review inconsistencies and presentation deadlines |
| Article 15 | Addresses action following a complying presentation | The Confirming Bank honours or negotiates and forwards the documents | Confirm that a Complying Presentation has been made |
| Article 16 | Governs refusal, Waiver, and notice of discrepancies | The Confirming Bank may refuse a discrepant presentation | Review the refusal notice and applicable deadline |
| Article 28 | Governs insurance documents and coverage | Important where CIF or CIP credits require insurance documents | Review issuer, signature, date, currency, amount, and risks covered |
Separate Undertakings of the Issuing Bank and Confirming Bank
The substantive value of a Confirmed L/C is that the Issuing Bank and Confirming Bank each assume an undertaking under the credit.
After confirmation has been validly added, a complying presentation made to the Confirming Bank or another permitted bank engages the Confirming Bank’s obligation to honour or negotiate according to the availability of the credit.
The Confirming Bank’s obligation is not conditional solely on receiving reimbursement from the Issuing Bank.
Where the Issuing Bank suffers financial difficulty, suspends payment, or becomes insolvent, the Confirming Bank’s obligation normally remains where the presentation is complying, the confirmation is valid, and no applicable law prohibits payment.
Separate issues may nevertheless arise from the credit of the Confirming Bank, amendments not covered by confirmation, discrepancies, expiry, presentation at an incorrect place, fraud-related court orders, or mandatory sanctions restrictions.
Ordinary L/C, Confirmed L/C, and Silent Confirmation
| Item | Ordinary L/C | Confirmed L/C | Silent Confirmation | Practical Point |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Main undertaking | Issuing Bank | Issuing Bank and Confirming Bank | Issuing Bank and a bank under a separate agreement with the Beneficiary | Silent Confirmation terms differ among banks |
| UCP 600 Confirmation | None | Confirmation under Articles 2 and 8 | Normally not a UCP 600 Confirmation | Review the contractual structure rather than the label |
| Issuing Bank authorisation or request | Not applicable | Required for formal confirmation | May not exist | Determine whether the bank is a formal Confirming Bank |
| Visible on the credit | No confirmation | Confirmation is stated in the Confirming Bank’s advice | May not be visible on the face of the credit | Issuing Bank instructions alone do not prove confirmation |
| Issuing Bank risk | Remains with the Beneficiary | May be replaced to an extent by the credit of the Confirming Bank | Depends on the separate agreement | A complying presentation remains essential |
| Country risk | Beneficiary remains exposed to the Issuing Bank’s jurisdiction | May be mitigated to an extent | Depends on the events covered by the agreement | Sanctions or mandatory law may still prevent payment |
| Cost | Ordinary issuance, advising, and negotiation charges | Additional confirmation commission | Separate risk-assumption fee | Cost varies by amount, tenor, country, and bank |
Meaning of CONFIRM, MAY ADD, and WITHOUT
A SWIFT documentary credit may use CONFIRM, MAY ADD, or WITHOUT as an instruction relating to confirmation.
| Code | Meaning for the Receiving Bank | What the Beneficiary Must Confirm | Practical Warning |
|---|---|---|---|
| CONFIRM | The Issuing Bank requests the receiving bank to add confirmation | An advice expressly stating that confirmation was added | The CONFIRM code alone does not make the credit confirmed |
| MAY ADD | The Issuing Bank authorises the receiving bank to add confirmation | Whether the bank added confirmation or offered conditions | The receiving bank may decline to confirm |
| WITHOUT | The receiving bank is not requested to add confirmation | That the credit is advised without confirmation | Any separate Silent Confirmation must be distinguished |
The obligation of the Confirming Bank begins when the bank actually adds its confirmation, not when the Issuing Bank merely sends a CONFIRM or MAY ADD instruction.
A bank authorised or requested to confirm may decline after completing its credit and compliance review.
It may then inform the Issuing Bank and advise the credit to the Beneficiary without confirmation.
Advising Bank, Confirming Bank, and Nominated Bank
| Bank | Main Role | Obligation against a Complying Presentation | Wording to Review | Common Misunderstanding |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Advising Bank | Authenticates and advises the credit | Normally none unless confirmation is added | Advice and without confirmation wording | Assuming the Advising Bank will pay |
| Confirming Bank | Adds its undertaking to that of the Issuing Bank | Must honour or negotiate a complying presentation | Express confirmation wording | Assuming that an instruction to confirm proves confirmation |
| Nominated Bank | Bank with which the credit is available | Normally none unless it confirms or expressly agrees to act | Available with and Available by | Treating nomination as confirmation |
| Negotiating Bank | Purchases drafts or documents | Depends on confirmation and the separate negotiation agreement | With or without recourse | Treating negotiation as equivalent to confirmation |
Availability and Place for Presentation
A Confirmed L/C must identify the bank, method, place, and time for use of the credit.
| Item | Illustrative Wording | Meaning | Common Problem |
|---|---|---|---|
| Available with | Available with Confirming Bank | Identifies the bank with which the credit is available | Presentation to another bank may not engage the confirmation |
| Available by | Sight Payment, Deferred Payment, Acceptance, or Negotiation | Identifies the payment or negotiation method | The Confirming Bank’s performance differs by availability |
| Place for Presentation | Tokyo, Singapore, or another place | Identifies where documents must be presented | Presentation at another office or jurisdiction may be invalid |
| Expiry Date | Stated calendar date | Final date for use of the credit | A presentation within 21 days after shipment may still be after expiry |
| Latest Shipment Date | Stated calendar date | Final permitted shipment date | An extension may not be covered by confirmation |
| Presentation Period | Within 15 days after shipment | Time allowed after shipment for presentation | The credit may impose less than the UCP maximum period |
Amendments and Scope of Confirmation
Confirmation does not automatically extend to every amendment of a Confirmed L/C.
The Confirming Bank may extend confirmation to an amendment or may advise the amendment without extending its confirmation.
| Amendment | If Confirmation Is Extended | If Confirmation Is Not Extended | Beneficiary Review |
|---|---|---|---|
| Increase in credit amount | The increased amount is covered | The increase may remain supported only by the Issuing Bank | Maximum confirmed amount |
| Extension of expiry | The extended period is covered | The Confirming Bank may remain bound only until the original expiry | Final date of confirmation |
| Extension of shipment date | Shipments during the extended period are covered | Later shipments may fall outside confirmation | Confirmation wording in the amendment advice |
| Longer payment tenor | The longer deferred or acceptance period is covered | The additional tenor may be unconfirmed | Maturity and additional commission |
| New documents or changed conditions | Compliance is assessed against the amended conditions | Only the Issuing Bank may be bound by the changed conditions | Express approval by the Confirming Bank |
Acceptance of an amendment by the Beneficiary does not itself mean that the Confirming Bank has extended confirmation to the amended terms.
The confirmation status must be checked for each amendment.
Risks Mitigated and Not Mitigated by Confirmation
| Risk | Effect of Confirmation | Why Protection May Be Limited | Additional Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Issuing Bank default | May be mitigated against a complying presentation | Depends on valid confirmation and the credit of the Confirming Bank | Review the Confirming Bank |
| Transfer restriction in the Issuing Bank’s country | May be mitigated where the Confirming Bank pays in another jurisdiction | Payment-currency sanctions and mandatory law may remain relevant | Review the payment currency and bank locations |
| Applicant insolvency | Direct impact is reduced by the bank undertakings | The banks normally require a complying presentation | Control documentary compliance |
| Discrepancy | Not mitigated | The confirmation undertaking depends on compliance | Conduct pre-shipment and draft-document review |
| Defective or short cargo | Not mitigated | Banks examine documents rather than goods | Use inspection documents and sale-contract remedies |
| Expired credit | Not mitigated | The undertaking operates only within the credit period | Allow sufficient operational time |
| Sanctions or legal prohibition | Not necessarily mitigated | UCP 600 does not override mandatory law | Obtain banking and legal review |
| Confirming Bank default | Not mitigated | The Confirming Bank itself has credit risk | Select the Confirming Bank carefully |
Situations Where Confirmation May Be Appropriate
| Situation | Reason for Confirmation | Items to Confirm | Possible Alternative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Concern regarding the Issuing Bank | Adds the undertaking of another bank | Confirming Bank credit and confirmed amount | Change of Issuing Bank or advance payment |
| Foreign-exchange shortage in the importing country | May reduce dependence on outward remittance from that country | Confirming Bank location and payment currency | Export-credit insurance or different currency |
| Political or economic instability | May mitigate defined forms of country risk | Covered risks, law, and sanctions | Trade insurance or advance payment |
| High-value transaction | Reduces concentration on one foreign bank | Limit, amount, tenor, and commission | Split shipments or several banks |
| Long-tenor Usance L/C | Reduces Issuing Bank risk until maturity | Confirmation period, maturity, and discounting | Forfaiting or trade insurance |
| Exporter requires early negotiation | May support negotiation by the Confirming Bank | Available by Negotiation and recourse terms | Ordinary negotiation or negotiation under indemnity |
| Internal exporter policy requires confirmation | Meets board or credit-control requirements | Approved banks, rating, and country limit | Trade insurance or advance payment |
Situations Not Treated as a Confirmed L/C
| Situation | Why It Is Not Treated as a Confirmed L/C | Alternative Framework | Documents to Review |
|---|---|---|---|
| Credit advised without confirmation | The Advising Bank has not added a payment undertaking | Assess the transaction as an ordinary L/C | Credit advice and confirmation wording |
| Silent Confirmation | It is normally not Confirmation under UCP 600 Article 8 | Apply the separate agreement between the bank and Beneficiary | Silent Confirmation agreement |
| D/P or D/A collection | There is no documentary-credit undertaking by an Issuing Bank | Review URC 522, collection terms, and trade insurance | Collection Instruction and draft |
| Open-account or remittance transaction | No documentary credit exists | Consider export-credit insurance, advance payment, or a guarantee | Sale contract and payment terms |
| Standby L/C or Demand Guarantee | The purpose and drawing structure differ from a commercial L/C | Review ISP98, UCP 600, or URDG 758 as applicable | Full standby or guarantee text |
| Expired credit | The confirmation period may also have ended | Negotiate an extension or another payment arrangement | Expiry Date and Amendment |
| Payment prohibited by sanctions law | The contractual undertaking cannot override mandatory law | Obtain legal and sanctions review | Parties, goods, banks, countries, and currency |
Alternatives When a Bank Declines to Confirm
| Alternative | Basic Structure | Benefit | Main Point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Change of Issuing Bank | Credit is reissued by a more acceptable bank | May remove the need for confirmation | The importer must be able to change banks |
| Silent Confirmation | Separate risk arrangement between the exporter and a bank | May be available where formal confirmation is not requested | It is not identical to UCP 600 confirmation |
| Export-credit or trade insurance | Insurance covers specified buyer, bank, or country risks | May be used where bank confirmation is unavailable | Review exclusions, waiting periods, and insured percentage |
| Advance payment | All or part of the price is received before shipment | Directly reduces exporter collection risk | The importer may not accept the requirement |
| Split transaction | Shipment and payment are divided among several credits | Reduces concentration in a single transaction | Transport and documentary costs increase |
| Shorter tenor | Usance is changed to sight or a shorter period | Reduces the duration of credit exposure | Increases the importer’s funding burden |
Discrepant Presentations
A Confirming Bank is normally not required to perform its Article 8 undertaking where the presentation is discrepant.
The Confirming Bank may seek a Waiver from the Issuing Bank or Applicant. A Waiver by the Issuing Bank does not necessarily require the Confirming Bank to accept the discrepant presentation under its confirmation.
| Response | Structure | Position of the Confirming Bank | Main Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Correct the documents | Correctable documents are replaced before the deadline | The confirmation operates if the new presentation complies | Correction may not be completed before expiry |
| Obtain a Waiver | The Issuing Bank accepts the discrepancy following Applicant approval or other review | The Confirming Bank may make its own decision | The Beneficiary may lose the benefit of confirmation |
| Negotiation under indemnity | The bank negotiates against an indemnity from the exporter | This is separate from performance of the confirmation undertaking | The bank may have recourse to the exporter |
| Collection basis | Documents are forwarded without reliance on the credit undertaking | The Confirming Bank may have no payment obligation | Payment timing and collection become uncertain |
| Refusal or return | The documents are rejected and remain unpaid | No confirmation obligation arises | Cargo disposal, storage costs, and buyer dispute may follow |
Stale B/L and Presentation Deadlines
Under UCP 600 Article 14, a presentation including an original transport document must generally be made no later than 21 calendar days after shipment and, in any event, no later than the expiry date of the credit.
A shorter period stated in the credit, such as 15 days after shipment, must be observed.
| Deadline | Meaning | Item to Confirm | Effect of Delay |
|---|---|---|---|
| Latest Shipment Date | Final permitted shipment date | On Board Date | Possible Late Shipment Discrepancy |
| Presentation Period | Time allowed after shipment for presentation | Period stated in the credit | Possible stale transport document or late presentation |
| Expiry Date | Final date of availability of the credit | Business day and closing time at the place for presentation | The credit expires |
| Bank examination period | Time allowed for the bank to determine compliance | Up to five banking days after presentation | Separate from the Beneficiary’s presentation period |
Confirmation does not require the Confirming Bank to accept a late presentation.
The exporter must plan backwards from the presentation deadline and allow sufficient time to obtain the B/L, insurance document, certificate of origin, inspection certificate, and other required documents.
Insurance Documents and UCP 600 Article 28
Where a CIF or CIP credit requires an insurance document, actual effectiveness of the cargo insurance and documentary compliance under the credit are separate issues.
| Review Item | Main Requirement | Typical Discrepancy | Practical Response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Issuer and signature | Issued and signed by an insurance company, underwriter, or authorised agent or proxy | Authority or signing capacity is unclear | Confirm the signature capacity and agency wording |
| Number of originals | Required originals must be presented where more than one is issued | Only part of the original set is presented | Confirm the number issued on the document |
| Insurance date | Normally no later than shipment, unless cover is shown effective from an earlier date | The insurance document is dated after shipment | State the effective attachment date |
| Insured amount | Amount required by the credit or calculated under Article 28 | Insurance is below the required percentage or amount | Share the Invoice, CIF or CIP value, and currency |
| Currency | Normally the same currency as the credit | Insurance and credit currencies differ | Confirm the currency before issuance |
| Risks covered | Must meet risks and coverage required by the credit | War, Strikes, All Risks, or another required cover is missing | Provide the full credit to the insurer and Insurance Agent |
| Transit | Must cover the route required by the credit | From, To, or intermediate location does not match | Confirm the route and final destination |
The exporter should provide the insurer or Insurance Agent with the full credit, all amendments, the Invoice, the transport route, and the expected shipment date rather than sending only an extract of the insurance requirement.
Confirmation Commission and Allocation of Charges
| Pricing Factor | Description | Practical Effect | Item to Confirm |
|---|---|---|---|
| Credit of the Issuing Bank | Bank risk assumed by the Confirming Bank | Lower credit may increase cost or prevent confirmation | Availability of a confirmation limit |
| Country of the Issuing Bank | Political, transfer, foreign-exchange, and sanctions risk | High-risk countries may be declined | Country limit |
| Credit amount | Maximum exposure of the Confirming Bank | An increase may attract additional commission | Confirmed amount |
| Validity and payment tenor | Period from issuance or shipment to final maturity | Longer Usance may increase cost | Expiry and Maturity |
| Currency | Payment currency and funding conditions | Liquidity and cost differ by currency | Payment currency |
| Amendments | Changes in amount, expiry, shipment, or terms | Amendment and additional confirmation fees may arise | Party responsible for charges |
The sale contract and credit should state whether confirmation charges are borne by the Beneficiary or Applicant.
Where confirmation costs are not included in the export price and are discovered only after receipt of the credit, the profitability of the transaction may be materially reduced.
Cases That Commonly Cause Practical Problems
| Case | Main Problem | Documents to Check | Key Judgment Point | Initial Response |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CONFIRM appears in the SWIFT message but the advice contains no confirmation wording | The bank may not have added confirmation | SWIFT message and bank advice | Whether confirmation was expressly added | Obtain written confirmation from the bank |
| The exporter assumes that the Advising Bank is the Confirming Bank | Issuing Bank and country risk remain with the exporter | Advice and original credit | Whether an Article 8 undertaking exists | Arrange confirmation or an alternative before shipment |
| Confirmation was not extended to an increase | The additional amount may be covered only by the Issuing Bank | Original credit and amendment advice | Maximum confirmed amount | Request confirmation of the increase |
| B/L Consignee differs from the credit | A Discrepancy prevents operation of the confirmation undertaking | Credit and B/L Draft | Whether correction is possible before the deadline | Conduct B/L draft review before issuance |
| Documents are presented more than 21 days after shipment | Possible late presentation | On Board Date and presentation receipt | Presentation Period stated in the credit | Obtain all documents before the deadline |
| Insurance amount is insufficient | The insurance may exist but the document is discrepant | Credit, Invoice, and insurance document | Article 28 and required amount | Correct the insurance document before expiry |
| Confirming Bank suspends payment because of sanctions | The contractual undertaking conflicts with mandatory law | Parties, goods, currency, and sanctions review | Applicable jurisdiction and prohibition | Obtain bank legal and trade-control advice |
| Silent Confirmation is treated as formal confirmation | UCP rights and separate contractual rights are confused | Silent Confirmation agreement and credit | Covered risks and payment conditions | Reconfirm the agreement with the bank |
Decision Flow for Using a Confirmed L/C
- Determine whether the sale contract requires confirmation.
- Review the credit of the proposed Issuing Bank and its country risk.
- Identify an acceptable Confirming Bank and available confirmation limit.
- Agree on responsibility for confirmation commission.
- Include the confirmation request or authorisation in the L/C application.
- After issuance, review whether the instruction states CONFIRM, MAY ADD, or WITHOUT.
- Check the bank advice to confirm that confirmation was actually added.
- Review Available with, Available by, place for presentation, expiry, and shipment deadline.
- Provide documentary requirements to all document issuers before shipment.
- Conduct draft review of the B/L, Invoice, insurance document, and other documents.
- For each amendment, confirm whether confirmation was extended.
- Present documents by calculating backwards from the Presentation Period and Expiry Date.
- If a Discrepancy arises, distinguish correction, Waiver, negotiation under indemnity, and collection.
- After payment or negotiation, review charges, maturity, reimbursement, and return of documents.
Example 1: Issuing Bank Suspends Payment
A Japanese exporter ships machinery worth USD 2 million under a Confirmed L/C payable 180 days after shipment.
The exporter makes a timely presentation of a complying B/L, Invoice, insurance document, inspection certificate, and other required documents to the Confirming Bank.
The Issuing Bank subsequently experiences financial difficulty and suspends outward payments.
Where the Confirming Bank validly confirmed both the credit and the 180-day payment terms, and the presentation is complying, its undertaking does not disappear solely because it cannot obtain reimbursement from the Issuing Bank.
This is a central example of mitigation of Issuing Bank risk through confirmation.
Example 2: B/L Discrepancy under a Confirmed L/C
The credit requires the B/L Consignee to state “To Order of Issuing Bank.”
The House B/L issued by the NVOCC instead names the importer as Consignee and is presented to the Confirming Bank without correction.
The Confirming Bank identifies a Discrepancy because the B/L does not comply with the credit.
Confirmation does not require the bank to honour the discrepant presentation.
The exporter must consider whether the B/L can be corrected before expiry, whether a Waiver can be obtained, or whether the bank will negotiate under separate recourse conditions.
Confirmation mitigates bank and country risk; it does not eliminate documentary discrepancies.
Example 3: Amendment Not Covered by Confirmation
The original Confirmed L/C is for USD 1 million, with a latest shipment date of 30 June and expiry on 21 July.
The Issuing Bank later increases the amount to USD 1.5 million and extends the shipment date to 31 July.
The Confirming Bank advises the amendment but expressly states that it does not extend its confirmation to the amendment.
If the exporter accepts the amendment and ships USD 1.5 million of goods in July, the additional USD 500,000 and the extended shipment period may not be protected by the Confirming Bank’s undertaking.
The Beneficiary must confirm not only receipt of the amendment but also whether the Confirming Bank extended confirmation to the amended terms.
Freight Forwarder Involvement under the Standard Five Classifications
The five classifications used in this article are not established by law or industry-wide consensus. They serve as an analytical framework within this series to clarify the scope of freight forwarder involvement.
| Standard Five Classifications | Possible Work in a Confirmed L/C Transaction | Roles Normally Not Assumed | Documents Used to Determine Responsibility | Practical Point |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Simple Intermediary | Transmitting L/C conditions, bank responses, and documentary instructions | Final determination of the Confirming Bank’s undertaking or compliance | Instruction emails, transmission records, and scope of work | Distinguish transmission from banking advice |
| Cargo Transportation Service Provider | Coordinating shipment schedules, B/L drafts, terminal delivery, and document timing | Adding confirmation, granting a Waiver, or deciding bank payment | Transport contract, B/L Draft, and shipment records | Manage transport by calculating backwards from presentation deadlines |
| NVOCC / House B/L Issuer | Preparing the House B/L and controlling the On Board Date in accordance with the credit | Making the compliance decision of the Issuing Bank or Confirming Bank | House B/L, Master B/L, and credit terms | Review differences between House and Master B/Ls |
| Door-to-Door Single Contractor | Managing the operational schedule and required documents from collection through shipment | Guaranteeing collection under the documentary credit | Integrated transport contract, schedule, and document list | Control the effect of logistics delays on presentation deadlines |
| Agent or Coordinator for Specific Operations | Arranging insurance documents, inspection certificates, document recovery, or bank inquiries | Accepting amendments or waiving discrepancies beyond the mandate | Authority, application, and inquiry records | Define authority to negotiate with banks |
Contracting Carrier and Actual Carrier are legal or contractual status concepts and do not replace the Standard Five Classifications used in this article.
Operational work such as packing, storage, inspection, stowage, vanning, devanning, delivery to a CFS or CY, preparation of a B/L, arrangement of an insurance document, and domestic delivery does not by itself constitute a sixth classification.
Difference from Marine Cargo Insurance and Export-Credit Insurance
| Instrument | Main Risk | Main Payment Condition | Difference from a Confirmed L/C | Main Party to Consult |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Confirmed L/C | Issuing Bank risk and certain forms of country risk | Complying presentation under the credit | Documentary payment undertaking by banks | Confirming Bank |
| Marine cargo insurance | Physical loss of or damage to cargo during transit | Insured casualty, covered risk, duration, and proof of loss | Does not cover bank default or documentary discrepancy | Insurer and Insurance Agent |
| Export-credit insurance | Buyer non-payment and specified credit events | Insured credit event and waiting period | Does not depend solely on documentary compliance | Credit insurer and Insurance Agent |
| Trade insurance | Specified commercial and political risks | Covered event, insured percentage, exclusions, and claim requirements | May be used where bank confirmation is unavailable | Trade insurer and Insurance Agent |
| Silent Confirmation | Bank or country risks defined in a separate agreement | Contractual conditions agreed between the bank and Beneficiary | Normally not Confirmation under UCP 600 Article 8 | Providing bank |
Bank risk under a Confirmed L/C and physical cargo risk must be managed separately.
Where the transaction requires insurance documents or additional protection against commercial or political risks, the exporter should consult not only its transaction bank but also the Insurance Agent responsible for marine cargo, credit, or trade insurance.
Common Misunderstandings
| Misunderstanding | Actual Approach | Practical Point |
|---|---|---|
| A credit received through a bank is automatically confirmed | The Advising Bank must actually add confirmation | Review the bank’s confirmation wording |
| The SWIFT code CONFIRM means confirmation already exists | The bank becomes bound when it actually adds confirmation | Obtain an express confirmation advice |
| A Confirmed L/C must be paid despite discrepancies | The undertaking depends on a complying presentation | Review documentary requirements before shipment |
| An Issuing Bank Waiver automatically binds the Confirming Bank | The Confirming Bank may make its own decision on a discrepant presentation | Obtain the Confirming Bank’s written response |
| Every amendment is automatically confirmed | The Confirming Bank may decline to extend confirmation | Review the confirmation status of each amendment |
| The Confirming Bank guarantees cargo quality | Banks examine documents rather than goods | Use inspection conditions in the contract and credit |
| Confirmation removes sanctions and legal risk | Mandatory law may still prevent payment | Obtain advance bank and legal review |
| Silent Confirmation is UCP 600 confirmation | It is normally a separate agreement with the Beneficiary | Review covered risks and demand conditions |
| A valid insurance policy must comply with the L/C | Insurance effectiveness and documentary compliance are separate | Review Article 28 and the credit terms |
| Marine cargo insurance covers Issuing Bank default | Cargo insurance normally covers physical cargo loss | Use confirmation, credit insurance, or trade insurance for payment risk |
When a Bank, Trade-Finance Specialist, or Insurance Agent Should Be Consulted
| Issue | Main Party to Consult | Matters to Confirm | Why Early Review Is Necessary |
|---|---|---|---|
| It is unclear whether confirmation was added | Advising Bank and proposed Confirming Bank | Confirmation wording, amount, and period | The payment structure may be impossible to change after shipment |
| Credit of the Issuing Bank or country deteriorates | Transaction bank and trade-finance specialist | Confirmation limit, payment route, and alternative bank | New confirmation may become unavailable |
| Confirmation was not extended to an amendment | Confirming Bank and Issuing Bank | Confirmed amount, expiry, and payment tenor | The amended portion may remain unconfirmed |
| A Discrepancy occurs | Confirming Bank, Issuing Bank, and L/C specialist | Correction, Waiver, negotiation, and collection options | Presentation and expiry deadlines continue to run |
| Sanctions or export controls are relevant | Bank legal department, trade-control specialist, and lawyer | Parties, goods, country, currency, and payment banks | The confirmation undertaking alone cannot resolve mandatory-law restrictions |
| Compliance of an insurance document is unclear | Insurer, Insurance Agent, and transaction bank | Article 28, amount, currency, risks, date, and signature | Reissuance may require substantial time |
| The bank declines to confirm | Transaction bank, credit insurer, and Insurance Agent | Silent Confirmation, trade insurance, or advance payment | An alternative payment-protection structure is required before shipment |
Decision Checklist
| Review Stage | Party to Consult | Items to Confirm | Response if a Problem Is Found |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sale-contract stage | Exporter, importer, and transaction bank | Need for confirmation, designated bank, and allocation of charges | Renegotiate the price or payment terms |
| Before issuance | Issuing Bank and proposed Confirming Bank | Confirmation limit, country limit, amount, and tenor | Change the Issuing Bank or payment method |
| Receipt of the credit | Advising Bank | Authenticity and CONFIRM, MAY ADD, or WITHOUT instruction | Do not rely on confirmation before it is added |
| Addition of confirmation | Confirming Bank | Express wording, confirmed amount, expiry, and availability | Request additional confirmation for any gap |
| Credit review | Exporter, freight forwarder, and bank | Shipment, presentation, documents, and B/L requirements | Request an amendment before shipment |
| Amendment stage | Confirming Bank and Issuing Bank | Whether confirmation extends to the amendment | Do not accept an unconfirmed amendment without risk review |
| B/L preparation | NVOCC, shipping line, and freight forwarder | Consignee, Notify Party, On Board Date, and number of originals | Correct the draft before issuance |
| Insurance-document preparation | Insurer and Insurance Agent | Article 28, amount, currency, date, and risks covered | Obtain a corrected document before expiry |
| Presentation | Confirming Bank or Nominated Bank | Place, Presentation Period, and Expiry Date | Re-present to the correct bank before the deadline |
| Discrepancy stage | Confirming Bank, Issuing Bank, and importer | Correction, Waiver, and acceptance by the Confirming Bank | Compare collection and negotiation-under-indemnity risks |
| Payment or negotiation | Confirming Bank | With or without recourse, charges, and maturity | Obtain written confirmation of recourse and costs |
| Deterioration of bank or country risk | Transaction bank, trade-finance specialist, and Insurance Agent | Continuation of confirmation, sanctions, trade insurance, and alternative payment | Suspend further shipment and restructure payment protection |
Summary
A Confirmed L/C is a documentary credit under which a Confirming Bank adds its own undertaking, in addition to that of the Issuing Bank, to honour or negotiate a complying presentation.
It may mitigate the exporter’s exposure to the credit of the Issuing Bank, foreign-exchange shortages, transfer restrictions, and political or economic instability in the Issuing Bank’s country.
Under UCP 600, the obligations of the Issuing Bank and Confirming Bank exist separately. Where confirmation has been validly added and a complying presentation is made, the Confirming Bank’s obligation does not automatically disappear solely because reimbursement cannot be obtained from the Issuing Bank.
The undertaking is not unconditional. Documents must comply with the credit, UCP 600, and international standard banking practice and must be presented to the correct bank, at the correct place, and within the applicable period.
A CONFIRM or MAY ADD instruction from the Issuing Bank does not by itself mean that confirmation has already been added. The Beneficiary must obtain an advice expressly confirming the undertaking of the Confirming Bank.
Where the credit is amended, the Beneficiary must determine whether the Confirming Bank extended confirmation to the amendment. An increase, extension, or revised payment tenor is not automatically covered by the original confirmation.
Confirmation does not eliminate a Discrepancy, stale transport document, expired credit, defective cargo, Confirming Bank credit risk, or a payment prohibition arising from mandatory law.
Silent Confirmation is normally a separate contractual arrangement rather than Confirmation under UCP 600 Article 8. Its covered risks, payment conditions, and recourse provisions must be determined from the agreement.
Where a CIF or CIP credit requires insurance documents, actual insurance coverage and compliance of the insurance document under UCP 600 Article 28 must be reviewed separately.
Before shipment, the parties should review the Issuing Bank, Confirming Bank, confirmed amount, amendments, presentation period, insurance documents, discrepancy procedures, confirmation commission, and available trade-insurance alternatives as one integrated payment-risk process.
