Loss of Market in Cargo Claims: Price Decline, Lost Sales and Insurance Treatment
What Is Loss of Market?
Loss of Market refers to commercial losses arising when cargo cannot be sold in the originally planned market, at the scheduled time, price, or to the intended buyer.
Due to import refusals, customs clearance delays, quarantine holds, transport delays, lost sales seasons, buyer rejection, market price drops, and similar events, cargo may physically exist and have no quality defects, yet cannot be sold as planned.
The core of Loss of Market lies not in the physical damage to the cargo itself, but in the inability to sell the cargo as scheduled.
Therefore, it is necessary to separately classify the nature of losses such as physical loss or damage to the cargo, the cargo’s value lost due to import refusal, and additional charges like disposal, disinfection, or return.
Under ordinary marine cargo insurance, Loss of Market caused by delay, market fluctuations, loss of buyers, or lost expected profits—rather than physical damage to the cargo—is generally excluded or can become a major point of dispute.
Scope Covered in This Article
| Item | Content Covered in This Article | Content to Confirm Separately |
|---|---|---|
| Loss of Market | Commercial losses due to missed sales timing, market price decline, buyer cancellation, and lower resale prices | Individual endorsements, delay insurance, sales contracts, and damage calculation methods |
| Physical Damage to Cargo | Distinction from damage to the cargo itself such as water damage, breakage, theft, temperature deviation, etc. | Covered risks, exclusions, proximate cause, surveys, and damage assessment |
| ICC 2009 Clause 4.5 | Exemptions related to damage and costs arising from delay | The actual ICC edition applied, individual clauses, and changes by endorsements |
| Rejection Insurance | Situations where cargo value concerns arise from import refusal by government or administrative authorities | Target countries, covered items, reasons for refusal, authority orders, and insurance coverage scope |
| Rejection Expenses | Costs after import refusal such as disinfection, fumigation, inspection, disposal, storage, and re-export | Applicable expenses, necessity, prior approval, limits, and deductibles |
| Ship Back Expenses | Costs related to returning or re-exporting cargo to the export country or a third country | Return destination, re-export procedures, freight, customs fees, and coverage conditions |
| Sue and Labour | Reasonable expenses to prevent or reduce recoverable cargo damages, distinguished from Loss of Market | Expense necessity, notification to the insurance company, applicable damages, and clause wording |
| Buyer’s Refusal to Accept | Distinction between import refusal by authorities and commercial refusal by the buyer’s choice | Sales contract, quality terms, payment conditions, contract termination, and damage claims |
| Food and Seasonal Goods | Impact of best-before dates, demand periods, freshness, market prices, and sales deadlines | Decay and Deterioration, temperature conditions, regulations, and individual underwriting |
| Freight Forwarder Practice | Methods for organizing documentation by categorizing cargo damage, import refusal costs, and sales losses | Insurance claim payment judgments, sales contract liability, and carrier liability final decisions |
Losses Arising from Loss of Market
The issue with Loss of Market is not the physical loss or damage to the cargo itself, but rather losses caused by changes in the sales environment, demand, market price, timing of sales, or trading relationships with buyers.
Typical losses include the following:
- Loss due to price reduction caused by missing the sales season
- Inventory loss due to inability to sell as a seasonal product
- Difference loss caused by a decline in market price or market conditions
- Loss caused by the originally planned buyer refusing to accept delivery
- Difference loss from reselling at a lower price to a different buyer or another market
- Loss of initially expected sales profit or contract profit
- Additional sales expenses incurred due to losing the sales outlet
- Future losses resulting from reduced brand value or credibility
- Loss caused by missing events, exhibitions, campaigns, or planned sales start dates
These losses arise not from the physical condition of the cargo, but from changes in the commercial conditions surrounding the cargo.
Differences Between Cargo Damage and Loss of Market
| Situation | View as Cargo Damage | View as Loss of Market | Main Supporting Documents |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cargo was wetted or damaged. | Considered as physical damage to the cargo itself. | Differentiates between price reduction due to physical damage and price decline due to market conditions. | Photos, survey reports, repair/disposal quotations |
| Cargo arrived undamaged but delayed. | Generally difficult to evaluate as cargo damage if no physical damage occurred. | Issues such as lost sales timing, buyer cancellation, or market decline arise. | Transportation records, arrival dates, sales contracts, cancellation notices |
| Market prices dropped after import. | If no abnormality in quality or quantity of the cargo itself, this is separate from physical damage. | Typically a commercial loss caused by market price fluctuations. | Market price data, sales contracts, resale records |
| Buyer refused to accept the cargo. | If due to quality damage, confirm the presence or absence of physical damage. | When caused by timing, price, or buyer’s business circumstances, it tends to be a commercial risk. | Refusal notices, inspection results, sales contracts |
| Remaining shelf life has shortened. | Confirm whether there is spoilage, deterioration, or quality degradation. | Loss of Market may apply if quality is still normal but sales conditions have worsened. | Quality inspections, shelf life, sales standards, temperature records |
| Cargo was discarded due to non-compliance with standards. | Confirm if quality changes resulted from insured incidents during transport. | Sometimes the main issue is import refusal or contract non-conformity, rather than a lost market. | Official orders, test results, manufacturing records, insurance terms |
Cargo damage and Loss of Market can coexist within the same case.
For example, if part of the goods were soiled due to water damage during transport, and the remaining undamaged goods missed a sales campaign, the physical damage to the soiled portion and the commercial loss due to the missed campaign are assessed separately.
ICC 2009 Clause 4.5 and Delay Exclusion
Under ICC 2009 Institute Cargo Clauses (A) Clause 4.5, losses or expenses arising from delay are generally excluded, even if the delay results from a risk covered by the insurance. However, costs related to general average and salvage charges as set out in Clause 2 are treated separately.
This delay exclusion is important to consider when dealing with Loss of Market.
For example, even if a vessel accident qualifies as an insured peril, a delay caused by that accident resulting in missing the sales season does not automatically mean that reduced profits or a market drop are covered by marine cargo insurance solely because the accident occurred.
| Proximate Cause of Loss | Typical Losses | Basic Considerations | Points to Confirm |
|---|---|---|---|
| Covered perils such as collision, overturning, water damage | Damage, wetting, shortage, quality deterioration | Considered as physical damage to the cargo. | Causal link between accident and damage |
| Delay | Loss of sales season, market decline, buyer cancellations | Confirm relation to delay exclusion in Clause 4.5. | Applicable clauses, special endorsements, primary cause of loss |
| Physical deterioration after transport accident | Decay from refrigeration failure or temperature damage | Confirm whether this is mere delay or a separate physical loss. | Temperature logs, power records, quality inspections |
| Market price fluctuations | Difference between expected price and actual selling price | Usually considered a market risk if no damage to the cargo itself. | Market prices before and after the accident, sales records |
In practice, it is essential not to rely solely on statements such as "could not sell due to delay." One should confirm whether the proximate cause of the loss is physical damage to the cargo, delay, or market fluctuations that actually caused the loss.
Please note that the clause number and wording may vary depending on the ICC edition, insurance certificate, individual endorsements, and underwriting conditions.
Difference from Rejection Insurance, Rejection Expenses, and Ship Back Expenses
| Category | Main Subject | Examples | Difference from Loss of Market | Main Points to Confirm |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rejection Insurance | Damage due to loss of cargo value caused by import rejection by government or administrative authorities | Cargo cannot be imported due to official orders and is discarded or returned. | Loss relates to cargo value and is separate from profit loss or market price decline. | Covered items, reason for rejection, official order, insurance clause, coverage limit |
| Rejection Expenses | Additional costs reasonably incurred after import rejection | Inspection, disinfection, fumigation, disposal, storage, re-export, etc. | Actual expenses incurred and different in nature from Loss of Market. | Necessity, prior approval, invoice, expense limit |
| Ship Back Expenses | Costs for returning or re-exporting cargo to the export country or a third country | Return freight, export customs clearance costs, storage fees, domestic transport | Costs of cargo movement and separate from price loss or expected profit. | Return destination, transport method, quotation, insurer approval |
| Loss of Market | Commercial losses from losing the planned market, timing, price, or buyer | Market price decline, loss of sales season, buyer cancellation, loss of expected profit | Business disadvantage related to sales, not cargo value or additional actual expenses. | Presence of physical damage, delay, sales contracts, market price |
Even when Rejection Insurance is included, it does not automatically cover sales profit, expected profit, decline in market price, or loss of sales timing.
Similarly, even if Rejection Expenses or Ship Back Expenses are covered, Loss of Market caused by resale price decline or buyer cancellations is assessed separately.
Import Refusal by Authorities and Refusal of Receipt by Buyers
| Category | Refusing Party | Typical Reasons | Insurance Practice Perspective |
|---|---|---|---|
| Import Refusal by Authorities | Customs, Quarantine Offices, Regulatory Authorities for Food, Pharmaceuticals, etc. | Quarantine Violations, Ingredient Standards, Incomplete Labeling, Hygiene Standards, Insufficient Import Permit | Check whether Rejection Insurance or Rejection Expenses coverage applies. |
| Receipt Refusal due to Buyer’s Circumstances | Importer, Buyer, Resale Customer | Market Price Decline, Insufficient Funds, Loss of Resale Customer, Delivery Delay, Contract Cancellation | Usually treated as commercial risk under the sales contract or as Loss of Market. |
| Refusal over Quality Conditions | Buyer, Inspection Company, Resale Customer | Specification Mismatch, Quality Defects, Failure to Meet Contract Standards | Separate considerations for physical damage, contract non-conformance, and buyer claims. |
| Withholding during Authority Inspection | Customs, Quarantine Offices, Regulatory Authorities | Inspection, Analysis, Awaiting Additional Documents | Confirm whether this constitutes a formal import refusal or merely a procedural hold. |
The mere fact that the buyer refuses to receive the cargo does not automatically qualify as an import refusal covered by Rejection Insurance.
It is necessary to confirm the refusing party, refusal reasons, the existence of an official order, and the liabilities under the sales contract.
Relationship Between Sue and Labour and Loss of Market
Under ICC 2009 Clause 16, the insured, their employees, and agents are required to take reasonable measures to prevent or mitigate recoverable losses under the insurance, and to properly preserve and exercise rights against the carrier, bailee, or other third parties.
Expenses properly and reasonably incurred in accordance with these obligations may be considered under the policy terms.
However, Sue and Labour is not a system that changes Loss of Market—which is originally excluded—from non-covered to covered losses.
| Measures / Expenses | Situations Potentially Considered as Sue and Labour | Differentiation from Loss of Market | Points to Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Emergency transfer to refrigerated warehouse | Necessary to prevent spoilage or temperature damage to the cargo. | Aimed at mitigating physical damage to the cargo. | Confirm necessity, urgency, and reasonableness of expenses. |
| Fumigation / disinfection | Mitigates cargo damage potentially covered or losses after import refusal. | Does not cover the decline in sales price itself. | Check the relation with special clauses for Rejection Expenses. |
| Cargo sorting and repacking | Separates damaged from undamaged cargo to prevent further damage. | Handled separately from differences in resale price. | Keep work records and sorting results. |
| Sales expenses for finding new buyers | Normally part of commercial response to sales issues. | Tends to fall under Loss of Market or sales activity expenses. | Not automatically recognized as Sue and Labour expenses. |
| Discounted sale | May be done to preserve residual value of damaged cargo. | Distinguished from price reductions solely due to market depreciation. | Confirm insurer approval and causal relation to damage. |
| Claim notification to carrier | Preserves rights of recourse against third parties. | Separate issue from whether Loss of Market is covered. | Confirm deadlines for notice, evidence, limitation periods, and filing deadlines. |
Under the Marine Insurance Act 1906, if the policy contains a Sue and Labour Clause, that agreement is treated as ancillary to the insurance contract.
Whether incurred expenses are recoverable in practice depends on whether the loss involved is recoverable under the insurance, whether the measures were reasonable, and whether the insurer was consulted beforehand or early on.
Reasons Why Delay Damages Are Often Problematic for Food Cargo and Seasonal Products
Food products, agricultural and marine products, frozen and refrigerated cargo, seasonal items, event goods, and promotional products tend to have a limited sales period, making Loss of Market a significant risk for such cargo.
Even if the cargo itself is physically intact, delays of several days or weeks may cause the following issues:
- The demand period or sales season may pass.
- The remaining shelf life may fall below the buyer's standards.
- The buyer may purchase substitutes from other suppliers.
- Market supply may increase, causing price drops.
- Events, exhibitions, or promotional campaigns may conclude.
- Retailers may reassign shelf space or sales slots to other products.
Losses in sales due to these circumstances can be significant, yet they do not necessarily constitute physical damage to the cargo itself.
Typical Cases Difficult to Compensate
| Case | Main Cause | Documents to Check | Key Points for Judgment | Initial Response |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Market price dropped during customs clearance delay. | Inspection, incomplete documents, prolonged review, market fluctuations | Customs clearance records, market price data, sales contracts | Is it physical damage to cargo or only market price decline? | Separate records for cargo condition and price changes. |
| Christmas goods arrived after the sales season. | Vessel delay, port congestion, transshipment delay | Transport schedule, sales plan, arrival records | Is it loss of sales opportunity due to delay? | Keep records of buyer notifications and alternative sales. |
| Remaining shelf life shortened during quarantine hold. | Prolonged inspection, waiting for analysis results | Quarantine notices, shelf life data, quality inspections | Is it quality deterioration or only worsened sales conditions? | Continuously monitor temperature and quality conditions. |
| Buyer refused to accept goods due to market price drop. | Market price decline, contract terms, buyer’s circumstances | Refusal notice, market price data, sales contracts | Is it rejection by authorities or a commercial contract issue? | Obtain the refusal reason in writing. |
| After import refusal, goods were resold cheaply in a third country. | Regulatory non-compliance, government order, lack of alternative market | Official documents, resale contracts, cost breakdowns | Can cargo value, return shipping costs, and loss from discounts be separated? | Consult the insurance company before disposal or resale. |
| Frozen food remained normal but lost major sales channels. | Long-term storage, delivery delays, alternative procurement by buyers | Temperature records, quality inspections, cancellation notices | Is it a Loss of Market without physical damage? | Separate quality data and commercial loss documentation. |
| Exhibition cargo arrived after the exhibition ended. | Flight cancellations, document deficiencies, customs delays | Exhibition schedule, transport records, cargo condition | Is loss of exhibition opportunity considered cargo damage? | Organize costs for return shipment, storage, and alternative use. |
| Additional advertising costs incurred for discounted sales. | Buyer cancellation, lost sales season | Advertising expenses, sales records, pricing data | Is this a cost for loss mitigation or ordinary business expenses? | Document purpose and necessity before spending. |
Practical Example 1: When Fresh Produce Is Refused Import Due to Quarantine
Assume fruit worth ¥8,000,000 exported from Japan to Taiwan was found to carry a target pest during local quarantine inspection, and the import authorities requested either return or destruction of the cargo.
The return shipping cost was ¥1,200,000, and local storage and inspection costs were ¥500,000. After the return, the fruit was sold in a different market, but since the selling season had passed, the price was ¥3,000,000 lower than originally planned.
In this case, the loss in cargo value would be addressed under the Rejection Insurance coverage, while the inspection, storage, and return expenses should be checked against the Rejection Expenses or Ship Back Expenses terms.
Meanwhile, the ¥3,000,000 price reduction caused by the missed selling season is handled separately as Loss of Market.
Even if there is a special provision regarding import refusal, compensation does not automatically extend to the price reduction difference.
Practical Example 2: Long-Term Detention of Frozen Seafood at Customs
Suppose frozen seafood valued at 20,000,000 JPY imported from Vietnam to Japan was held at a port cold storage for 20 days due to ingredient inspection.
Temperature records during storage and quality inspections showed no abnormalities, and the cargo itself remained saleable. However, the initial buyer canceled the contract citing delay in delivery, and the resale price to another buyer decreased by 4,000,000 JPY.
The responsibility for refrigerated storage charges—whether covered by the import refusal expense endorsement, normal storage fees, or borne by the shipper—should be confirmed.
If no temperature damage or quality deterioration to the cargo is confirmed, the 4,000,000 JPY difference due to resale price is more likely to be classified as Loss of Market rather than physical cargo damage.
It is necessary to distinguish between the administrative process of detention for inspection and an official import refusal order.
Practical Example 3: When Seasonal Goods Arrive After Their Demand Period
Assume Christmas decorations valued at ¥12,000,000 imported from China to Japan arrive on December 27, 18 days later than scheduled due to congestion at the transshipment port and delay of the vessel.
Although there was no damage, wetting, or shortage of the cargo, the primary sales season had already ended, and the goods were sold as inventory for the following year or at clearance prices.
The main cause of this loss is not the physical damage to the cargo but the lost sales opportunity due to the delay.
Even if the delay resulted from a vessel accident or port incident, the relationship between the loss from price reductions due to lost sales opportunity and the delay exclusion in ICC 2009 Clause 4.5 should be confirmed.
It is also necessary to verify the delivery terms under the sales contract, the buyer’s cancellation rights, and whether any special arrangements for delay were made before shipment.
Practical Example 4: When a Food Authority’s Disposal Order and Anticipated Profit Coexist
Suppose a health food shipment valued at 15,000,000 JPY imported into Japan is found by the food authority to violate regulations on ingredient use, and a disposal order is issued.
Disposal and storage costs amount to 1,500,000 JPY, and the cargo owner also wishes to claim the anticipated profit of 6,000,000 JPY originally expected from sales.
Regarding the cargo value of 15,000,000 JPY, it is necessary to confirm that Rejection Insurance is attached and that the cause for rejection is covered under the policy.
For the disposal and storage costs of 1,500,000 JPY, review whether these qualify as Rejection Expenses covered by the policy, including approval procedures and limit amounts.
The anticipated profit of 6,000,000 JPY is a commercial expected profit distinct from the cargo value or disposal costs and should be assessed separately as Loss of Market.
Relation to Delay Insurance and Special Arrangements
Loss of Market or commercial loss due to delays is often difficult to cover under standard marine cargo insurance.
However, depending on the nature of the cargo, contracts, and projects, it may be possible to consider separate special arrangements related to delays, business interruptions, or specific lost sales opportunities, distinct from regular marine cargo insurance.
Cargo types commonly considered for such arrangements include:
- Cargo that must arrive in time for exhibitions or event dates
- Products with strong seasonality and a short sales period
- Project cargo subject to significant penalties for delayed delivery
- Machinery or plant cargo dependent on a specific equipment completion date
- Agricultural, marine, or commodity products with highly volatile market prices
Special arrangements cannot generally be applied to all cargo types. The insured events, waiting period, deductible period, damage calculation method, coverage limits, premiums, and required documentation should be individually confirmed.
Scope of Freight Forwarder Involvement
The Standard Five Classifications used in this article are not classifications established by laws or industry-wide standards. They serve as an analytical framework within this series to organize the scope of freight forwarder involvement regarding Loss of Market, import refusal, and related costs.
| Standard Five Classifications | Main Involvement in Loss of Market | Main Reference Documents | Points to Note When Judging Liability Scope |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple Intermediary | Conveys import refusal, quarantine holds, transport delays, and insurance company guidance to relevant parties. | Notification emails, intermediary logs, request content | Acts only as an information conduit and does not guarantee compensation for sales losses or insurance payouts. |
| Cargo Transportation Service Provider | Arranges cargo transport, storage, return shipments, or retransshipment to third countries. | Transportation contracts, quotations, delivery/return instructions | The contracted transport segment and the segment where the delay occurred should be confirmed. |
| NVOCC / House B/L Issuer | Issues House B/Ls and manages delay notifications in the transport contract, return shipments, or claims against the carrier. | House B/L, Clauses, transport notifications, incident records | Carrier liability and Loss of Market exclusions under marine cargo insurance should be assessed separately. |
| Door-to-Door Single Contractor | Integrally arranges transport, customs clearance, delivery, storage, and returns. | Through-transport contracts, scope of work, subcontract arrangements | Even with integrated arrangements, unlimited liability for lost prospective profits or market price declines is not assumed. |
| Agent/Coordinator for Specific Operations | Individually coordinates quarantine responses, inspections, destruction, storage, returns, surveys, or insurance notifications. | Individual mandates, work orders, coordination records | Cannot determine compensation eligibility or disposal authority beyond the assigned mandate scope. |
Contracting Carrier and Actual Carrier are legal or contractual concepts indicating a carrier’s liability status and do not replace the Standard Five Classifications used in this article.
Furthermore, operational tasks such as customs clearance, quarantine handling, storage, fumigation, destruction, returns, re-export, surveys, and sales coordination do not themselves form a sixth classification. It is necessary to confirm for whom, under which contractual position, and to what extent these tasks were contracted.
Common Misunderstandings
| Common Misunderstanding | Actual Perspective | Practical Response |
|---|---|---|
| If the cargo is rejected on import, marine cargo insurance will always pay out. | This depends on the cause of the import rejection, instructions from authorities, applicable clauses, and the type of covered damage. | Separate cargo value, additional charges, and loss of sales opportunities. |
| Damage due to delay is the same as physical cargo damage. | Physical damage to cargo and loss of sales opportunities caused by delay are distinct. | First confirm whether physical damage exists and identify the proximate cause. |
| Having Rejection Insurance also covers loss of sales profits. | Loss of cargo value due to import rejection and loss of sales profits or market price decline are separate types of damage. | Individually verify whether Loss of Market coverage is included. |
| Rejection Expenses also recover losses from price reductions. | Rejection Expenses mainly cover actual costs such as inspection, disinfection, disposal, or return shipping. | Delineate between expense damages and sales price differences. |
| Buyer's refusal to receive the goods is the same as official import rejection by authorities. | Refusal due to buyer’s circumstances is different from import rejection imposed by administrative authorities. | Confirm the rejecting party, reasons, and obtain formal documentation. |
| Market price decline is a type of damage to cargo value. | If there is no physical damage to cargo, loss due to market price fluctuation is generally considered a commercial loss. | Delineate between depreciation due to damage and market price decline. |
| If the insured risk causes delay, sales loss is also covered. | Under ICC 2009 Clause 4.5, delay caused by an insured risk may still be excluded from coverage. | Check the applicable clause and identify the proximate cause of the damage. |
| Sue and Labour coverage also compensates for sales loss. | Sue and Labour covers measures to prevent or mitigate recoverable cargo damage. | Confirm what types of damages and expenses the measures apply to. |
| If goods are sold at a reduced price, the difference can always be claimed under insurance. | This depends on whether the price reduction is to secure residual value of damaged cargo or is merely a market response. | Record the reason for the price reduction and obtain insurer approval. |
| The freight forwarder can judge whether an item is outside insurance coverage. | Final coverage decisions are made by the insurance company based on the policy wording and facts. | Organize the types of damage and confirm with the insurance company or insurance agent. |
Decision Checklist
| Situation | Party to Confirm | Items to Confirm | Actions if Issues Are Found |
|---|---|---|---|
| When Trouble is Identified | Cargo Owner, Warehouse, Freight Forwarder, Surveyor | Is there any damage, deterioration, shortfall in quantity, or temperature abnormality in the cargo? | Secure photos, inspection, temperature records, and survey reports. |
| At Import Refusal Confirmation | Customs, Quarantine Office, Importer, Customs Broker | Is it an official refusal order, inspection hold, or request for additional documents? | Obtain official documents from authorities, inspection results, and legal basis. |
| At Refusal Cause Confirmation | Authorities, Importer, Manufacturer, Customs Broker | Is it an issue related to labeling, ingredients, hygiene, quarantine, documentation, or Import Permit? | Compare with causes covered under the insurance clause. |
| When Costs Are Incurred | Warehouse, Customs Broker, Disposal Contractor, Freight Forwarder | Are the costs for inspection, storage, disinfection, disposal, return, or re-export? | Confirm prior approval and cost estimation. |
| When Sales Become Impossible | Cargo Owner, Buyer, Sales Department | Is it due to lost sales period, market price drop, buyer cancellation, or price decline? | Create a separate damage detail as Loss of Market. |
| When Confirming Delay | Shipping Line, Airline, Freight Forwarder, Warehouse | Cause and duration of delay, and presence of physical damage during delay | Differ between delay damages and cargo damages. |
| When Mitigating Damage | Cargo Owner, Insurance Company, Surveyor | Is transfer, sorting, repacking, disposal, or resale necessary? | Confirm approval as Sue and Labour or disposal of remnants. |
| When Confirming Insurance Terms | Insurance Company, Insurance Agent | ICC Clause 4.5, Rejection Insurance, Rejection Expenses, Ship Back Expenses | Check covered damages, limits, deductibles, and notification conditions. |
| When Buyer Refusal is Confirmed | Buyer, Cargo Owner, Trading Company | Is refusal caused by authorities or due to buyer factors such as delivery time, price, or funding circumstances? | Delineate responsibility under sales contract and insured damages. |
| When Carrier Claims Recourse | Freight Forwarder, Shipping Line, Airline, Carrier | Carrier liability, notification deadlines, and liability limits for delay or damage | Arrange insurance claims and carrier claims concurrently. |
| When Explaining to Cargo Owner | Cargo Owner, Insurance Agent, Freight Forwarder | Classification of cargo damage, additional charges, return costs, and Loss of Market | Explain by damage type without consolidating charges. |
Documents to Confirm
| Document | Information to Confirm | Practical Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Import Rejection Notice / Order from Authorities | Rejecting party, reason, date, disposal or return order | Confirms the official fact of import rejection. |
| Inspection Results / Analysis Report | Composition, hygiene, quarantine, quality, or labeling issues | Verifies the cause of rejection and cargo condition. |
| Cargo Photos / Survey Report | Physical damage, quality, quantity, and packaging condition | Differentiates cargo damage from Loss of Market. |
| Temperature Records / Quality Inspection | Temperature deviations and quality status of refrigerated/frozen cargo | Checks for physical deterioration. |
| Transportation Records | Scheduled date, actual arrival date, delay period, and causes | Organizes delay damages and cause of incident. |
| Sales Contract / Purchase Order | Price, delivery date, buyer, cancellation conditions, quality requirements | Confirms commercial loss and contractual liabilities. |
| Buyer’s Refusal / Cancellation Notice | Reason for refusal, notification date, buyer’s claims | Differentiates between authority rejection and buyer’s circumstances. |
| Market Price Data | Market prices before and after the incident, resale prices | Separates market depreciation from physical damage depreciation. |
| Resale Contract / Disposal Records | Actual sale price, buyer, residual value | Confirms reasons for price reduction and loss amount. |
| Storage / Inspection / Disposal Cost Details | Actual costs incurred after import rejection | Used to evaluate Rejection Expenses. |
| Return / Re-export Quotation | Return freight, customs fees, storage charges, domestic transport costs | Confirms the necessity of Ship Back Expenses. |
| Insurance Policy / Applicable Clauses | ICC clause, Rejection-related endorsements, limits, deductibles, and notification conditions | Confirms insurability by type of damage. |
| Records of Loss Mitigation Measures | Sorting, repacking, refrigerated transport, resale history, etc. | Checks relation to Sue and Labour clause or securing residual value. |
Matters to Confirm Before Shipment
For cargo where Loss of Market constitutes a significant risk, it is insufficient to confirm coverage eligibility only after an incident occurs.
Before shipment, the following points should be verified:
- The scope of physical damage covered by standard marine cargo insurance
- The scope of delay exclusions under ICC or similar clauses
- Covered countries, applicable products, and covered causes under Rejection Insurance
- The types of costs covered by Rejection Expenses and Ship Back Expenses
- Availability of special delay compensation or business interruption arrangements
- Import regulations, quarantine, composition, labeling, and hygiene standards
- Transport lead time in relation to sales deadlines, expiration dates, and demand periods
- Allocation of responsibilities for delay or import rejection under the contract with the buyer
- Alternative sales destinations, return locations, and disposal procedures
- Contact methods for the insurance company, surveyor, and local agents in the event of an incident
Loss of Market is a risk that cannot be managed by insurance alone. It requires management across sales contracts, import regulations, logistics schedules, inventory planning, and alternative sales strategies.
Practical Points
Loss of Market refers to commercial losses resulting from import refusal, delays, market price declines, buyer cancellations, or missed sales opportunities that prevent the cargo from being sold as originally planned.
If the cargo itself has damage, deterioration, or quantity shortages, these should be treated as cargo damage. When there is no physical damage but only a deterioration in sales conditions, this should be organized separately as Loss of Market.
Under ICC 2009 Clause 4.5, damages or costs arising from delay are excluded. Therefore, even if the insured peril caused the delay, compensation does not necessarily cover lost sales seasons or market price declines.
In import refusal cases, Rejection Insurance, Rejection Expenses, Ship Back Expenses, and Loss of Market are not handled collectively but categorized into cargo value, additional actual expenses, return shipping costs, and commercial losses, respectively.
Even when reasonable expenses for damage mitigation are considered under Sue and Labour, these apply only to costs aimed at preventing or reducing recoverable cargo damage. Loss of Market itself does not become a compensable item.
The freight forwarder is not in a position to decide whether insurance payment is made. They should clearly separate official documents, cargo condition, incurred expenses, reasons for inability to sell, buyer refusal reasons, and delay circumstances, and encourage the cargo owner to confirm with the insurance company or insurance agent.
Summary
Loss of Market refers to commercial losses resulting from the inability to sell cargo in the intended market, at the planned price, time, or to the designated buyer.
Unlike damage, wetting, theft, temperature damage, or shortages to the cargo itself, Loss of Market can occur even when the cargo is physically intact.
In cases of import refusal, the coverage for cargo value is addressed under Rejection Insurance, additional expenses under Rejection Expenses, return shipping costs under Ship Back Expenses, and lost sales opportunities under Loss of Market, all of which should be separately confirmed.
Under ICC 2009 Clause 4.5, damages or costs arising from delay are generally excluded, so losses from market price declines due to delayed arrival, missed sales timing, and buyer cancellations may not be covered under standard marine cargo insurance.
On the other hand, if physical damage or quality deterioration occurs due to a covered incident during transit, such physical loss should be considered separately from Loss of Market.
Damage mitigation measures and third-party rights protections under ICC 2009 Clause 16 are also important, but Sue and Labour provisions do not themselves provide coverage for Loss of Market.
For food products, refrigerated and frozen goods, fresh produce, marine products, seasonal items, exhibition cargo, and promotional goods, it is crucial to confirm delay exemptions, import refusal endorsements, sales deadlines, and alternative plans before shipment.
This article provides general practical explanations on Loss of Market, Rejection Insurance, Rejection Expenses, Ship Back Expenses, and Sue and Labour. It does not determine insurance payment, damage amounts, import refusal coverage, carrier liability, or contractual responsibility in specific cases.
Actual decisions should be made after reviewing the insurance policy, applicable clauses, endorsements, official documents, inspection results, sales contracts, transport records, cargo condition, and individual facts, and consulting with the insurance company or insurance agent.
