Ordinary Course of Transit in Cargo Insurance — Commencement, Termination and Assessment Criteria
What Is the ordinary course of transit?
ordinary course of transit refers to the condition in which cargo is in the usual flow of transportation as planned under the insurance contract. In Japanese, it is expressed as 「通常の輸送過程」.
Clause 8.1 of the ICC 2009 Transit Clause establishes a fundamental structure where insurance begins at the moment the cargo is first moved at the warehouse or storage place of origin for the commencement of transit, and continues while the cargo remains in the ordinary course of transit.
The important point here is that it is not only whether the cargo is physically moving. Even if cargo temporarily stops due to customs clearance, transshipment, port congestion, or waiting for delivery vehicles, if such detention is necessary to continue transportation, it could be considered within the ordinary course of transit.
On the other hand, if the cargo starts to be used for purposes such as awaiting sale, commercial stock, distribution, allocation, display, or long-term storage, it may be deemed to have left the ordinary course of transit, even if it physically remains at the port, CY, bonded warehouse, or inside the container.
Therefore, when determining the ordinary course of transit, it is necessary to confirm not only the cargo’s location but also the reason for detention, the purpose of storage, who chose the storage, and whether arrangements for the next transportation have been concretely made.
Scope Covered in This Article
| Item | Content Covered in This Article | Content Covered in Other Articles |
|---|---|---|
| ordinary course of transit | Criteria to distinguish between retention within the ordinary course of transit and transition to storage or inventory | Individual insurance policies, special clauses, and insurance claim decisions for each incident |
| Transit Clause | Basic structure of attachment of insurance, continuation of insurance, and termination of insurance under ICC 2009 Clause 8 | Details of coverage conditions and exclusions in ICC 2009 |
| Termination of insurance | Termination events from Clause 8.1.1 through Clause 8.1.4 and confirmation of the earliest occurring event | Marine cargo insurance periods and the 60-day rule in dedicated articles |
| Free Time and CY Storage | That shipping line’s tariff system and the insurance period under cargo insurance are determined independently | Demurrage, Detention, and free time cost calculations |
| Container Use for Storage Purposes | Assessment under Clause 8.1.3 when transport equipment or containers are used for storage purposes | Empty container return, Detention, and container damage liability |
| Termination of Contract of Carriage | Notices under Clause 9, requests for continuation of cover, additional premiums, and relationship with onward carriage within 60 days | Practical matters regarding termination of contract of carriage and marine cargo insurance |
| Delay and Forced Discharge | Continuation of insurance under Clause 8.3 and distinguishing delay exclusions | Individual considerations of forced discharge, deviation/change of voyage, and delay |
| Freight Forwarder Involvement | Practical scope urging confirmation of reasons for retention, storage purposes, transport plans, and insurance notification | Forwarder liability, carrier liability, and final insurance claim decisions |
This article is a fundamental analysis focused on determining whether cargo is within the ordinary course of transit. The acceptance or denial of insurance claims is made by the insurance company on a case-by-case basis, based on the actual insurance policy, applicable clauses, special clauses, cause of accident, timing of damage occurrence, and evidential documents.
Reasons to Distinguish Between the Ordinary Course of Transit and Storage Risks
Marine cargo insurance is generally designed to cover risks associated with transportation as specified in the insurance contract.
Cargo in transit faces transportation-specific risks such as collision, capsizing, cargo handling accidents, wet damage, breakage, theft, and transshipment accidents. On the other hand, risks related to long-term storage or commercial inventory differ from those of transportation, including fire, flooding, theft, temperature and humidity control, stacking, inventory concentration, and facility management.
When the storage location, storage duration, management entity, or aggregate cargo value changes, the nature of risks expected by the insurer at underwriting also changes. Therefore, it is necessary to distinguish whether the cargo is being temporarily stored to continue transportation, or if it has transitioned to storage, sales, or inventory management based on the insured's business decisions.
The ICC 2009 clauses do not comprehensively define the ordinary course of transit. In practice, judgment is made considering the following factors in combination:
- The direct purpose of the storage or delay
- The cause of the delay and whether it could be controlled
- Whether the insured or their employees chose the storage
- Whether the next transportation step is concretely planned
- Whether the cargo is maintained in a condition allowing immediate transportation
- Whether distribution, allocation, sale, processing, exhibition, or inventory management has started
- Whether the actual period of delay is within a reasonable timeframe for transportation
The Structure of Clause 8 and Clause 9 in ICC 2009
| Clause | Basic Content | Key Timing for Determination | Practical Points to Confirm | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clause 8.1 | Insurance attaches when the cargo is first moved to start transit and continues while in the ordinary course of transit | When the cargo is first moved at the place of origin | Place of origin stated on the policy, purpose of movement, immediate loading schedule | Simple movement inside a warehouse may not trigger attachment of insurance |
| Clause 8.1.1 | Terminates when unloading from the transport equipment is completed at the warehouse or storage place at the final destination | When unloading is completed at the final delivery location | Delivery location, unloading time, receipt records, delivery notes | Verify unloading completion, not merely arrival |
| Clause 8.1.2 | Terminates when unloading is completed at a warehouse or other place selected for storage, allocation, or distribution outside the ordinary course of transit | When unloading is completed at the chosen warehouse or place | Reasons for warehouse selection, storage instructions, distribution plan, inventory management start date | Termination may occur before arrival at the final destination |
| Clause 8.1.3 | Terminates when it is decided to use the transport equipment or container for storage outside the ordinary course of transit | When the choice is made to use the equipment for storage purposes | Reasons for container detention, duration of use, sales/inventory plans, instruction records | This may be a termination event without waiting for unloading |
| Clause 8.1.4 | Terminates 60 days after unloading from the ship at the final port of discharge | 60 days after completion of vessel discharge | Vessel discharge date, terminal records, insurance policy | Earlier termination reasons take precedence over the 60-day rule |
| Clause 8.2 | Sets limits where cargo is redirected to a place other than the insured destination after arrival at the final port of discharge | When the cargo is first moved toward the new destination | Instructions for destination change, date transfer starts, notification to insurer | Insurance coverage does not automatically extend to the new destination |
| Clause 8.3 | Maintains insurance during delays, deviations, forced discharge, reloading, transshipment, and similar events beyond the insured’s control | When changes in transit occur beyond the insured’s control | Cause, carrier notification, alternative transport plan, applicability of Clause 9 | Subject to termination events in Clause 8.1 and applicability of Clause 9 |
| Clause 9 | Defines termination and continuation requests where the transport contract ends unexpectedly at an unscheduled port or location | When the transport contract or transit is terminated prematurely | Termination notice, arrival date, notification to insurer, plans for onward transport | Timely notification and requests for continued coverage are critical |
| Clause 10 | Requires notification and agreement on conditions when the insured changes the destination after insurance attachment | When the insured decides or becomes aware of the destination change | Change instructions, date of awareness, new destination, additional conditions | Do not confuse with Clause 8.2 or Clause 9 |
The termination events described in Clause 8.1.1 through Clause 8.1.4 are subject to the first to occur among them.
Therefore, understanding the coverage as continuing simply because it is within 60 days after vessel discharge is not accurate. If unloading at the final warehouse, unloading at a warehouse outside the ordinary course of transit, or use of the container for storage purposes occurs first, insurance may terminate before the 60-day period elapses.
Criteria for Determining Whether Cargo Is Within the Ordinary Course of Transit or Has Transitioned to Storage
| Criteria | Conditions Possibly Considered as Within the Ordinary Course of Transit | Conditions Possibly Considered as Transitioned to Storage | Verification Documents |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose of Delay | Temporary delay to wait for customs clearance, transshipment, cargo handling, delivery vehicle, inspection, etc. | Storage for sales waiting, operational inventory, price adjustment, cash flow management, exhibition, etc. | Work instructions, customs clearance records, sales plans, storage instructions |
| Cause of Delay | Circumstances beyond the insured's control such as port congestion, customs inspection, shipping line convenience | Circumstances chosen by the insured, such as deliberately postponing pickup | Shipping line notifications, customs inquiries, cargo owner or importer emails |
| Next Transportation Arrangement | Delivery date, vehicle, delivery destination, and gate-out reservation are concretely confirmed | Delivery destination, delivery date, and sales destination are undecided; transportation arrangements are suspended | Delivery instructions, delivery reservations, vehicle arrangements, gate-out reservations |
| Cargo Condition | Seals and packaging are maintained, enabling immediate transfer to the next transportation stage | Unpacking, sorting, processing, price tagging, distribution, or inventory registration has commenced | Work records, photos, inventory ledgers, warehouse reports |
| Use of Container | Reasonably used as transportation equipment, such as short-term waiting for transportation | Kept long-term as a substitute warehouse, used for inventory storage | Retention instructions, delivery schedule, Detention records, onsite records |
| Storage Location | Temporary staging at locations commonly used in ordinary transit processes such as CY, CFS, bonded warehouses | Inventory management at commercial warehouses, sales warehouses, distribution centers, etc. | Warehouse contracts, purpose of receipt, storage title, inventory management records |
| Duration of Delay | Reasonable period typically required for transportation, customs clearance, inspection, or delivery coordination | Irregular long-term storage continuing without decisions on the subsequent stage | Arrival date, gate-out availability date, delay history, storage duration |
| Parties’ Recognition | Consistent confirmation of intent to continue transportation and concrete work | Internal decision to manage as operational inventory or stored cargo within the company | Internal approval documents, emails, sales department instructions, warehouse management classification |
A conclusion should not be drawn based on a single factor alone. Being within free time, located in a CY, issuance of a D/O, or the container remaining unopened are each only part of the evaluation materials.
Main Situations Where ordinary course of transit Applies
| Situation | Relation to ordinary course of transit | Main Application Conditions | Situations Where Application Is Problematic |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initial movement out of export warehouse | May be the attachment of insurance point under Clause 8.1 | There is intent to load cargo onto transport equipment and start transportation immediately | Movement for warehouse organization, shelf rearrangement, or inspection purposes only |
| Waiting at export CFS or CY for vessel loading | May be included if temporary detention is necessary for normal loading process | Booking and vessel schedule are valid, and cargo is in a condition ready for loading | Cargo stored long-term after booking cancellation |
| Temporary detention at transshipment port | May be included as part of normal transshipment process or continued under Clause 8.3 | Arrangements for transfer to next shipment are progressing and transport contract continues | Transport contract has been terminated and no onward forwarding arrangements exist |
| Waiting for customs clearance at import port | May be included if detention is necessary for normal import procedures | Declaration, inspection, and permit acquisition are being reasonably advanced | Ignoring document deficiencies and intentionally suspending cargo pickup |
| Waiting for delivery vehicle or delivery appointment | May be included if short-term waiting with a concrete delivery plan exists | Destination, vehicle, and delivery date/time are clearly confirmed | Indefinite storage due to an undetermined delivery destination |
| Customs inspection or administrative detention | May be recognized as delay beyond the insured's control | Reasonable and prompt response to inquiries or inspections | Failure to submit required documents, causing prolonged detention |
| Waiting for onward carriage after Forced Discharge | Subject to confirmation under Clause 8.3 or Clause 9 | Confirm continuation or termination of transport contract and notification status to insurer | Terminating transport contract without notifying insurer and leaving cargo unattended |
Situations Less Likely to Be Treated as Ordinary Course of Transit
| Situation | Reason for Issue | Relevant Clause | Necessary Actions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Storing cargo in a bonded warehouse until the buyer is determined | Shifted to a sales or inventory management purpose rather than transportation | Clause 8.1.2 | Consult with the insurer or insurance agent before starting storage |
| Starting distribution to multiple buyers at the warehouse | Could be considered allocation or distribution | Clause 8.1.2 | Confirm the timing of unloading, start date of distribution, and termination of insurance |
| Using containers as long-term storage instead of for transportation | Transport equipment is used for storage outside of ordinary course of transit | Clause 8.1.3 | Document the point of selection for storage purpose and verify insurance conditions |
| Holding cargo until the exhibition date | Storage arranged to match exhibition schedule, not for onward transportation | Clause 8.1.2 or Clause 8.1.3 | Separately confirm exhibition insurance, coverage during storage, and transshipment conditions |
| Withholding cargo due to change of buyer | Change in original destination, sales contract, or transportation purpose | Clause 8.2, Clause 10 | Notify the insurer without delay after decision on change |
| Storing cargo in warehouse waiting for price increase | Commercial inventory holding, not a necessary delay for transportation | Clause 8.1.2 | Confirm coverage for storage separate from marine cargo insurance |
Free Time and Marine Cargo Insurance Are Separate Systems
Free time is a fee-related period set by shipping lines or terminals, relating to container usage fees, Demurrage, Detention, and so forth.
Being within free time does not mean that the insurance period under marine cargo insurance is still in effect. Conversely, exceeding free time alone does not immediately terminate the insurance coverage.
| Comparison Item | Free Time | ordinary course of transit | Practical Considerations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose of the system | Fee management related to container and terminal usage | Clause-based concept to determine the marine cargo insurance period | Confirm fee systems and insurance periods separately |
| Setting authority | Shipping line, terminal, contract parties | Insurance contract, ICC, special clause | Do not determine insurance period based only on shipping line’s response |
| Judgment criteria | Vessel discharge day, gate-out day, empty container return day, etc. | Storage purpose, party choices, continuity of transport, etc. | Check both duration and underlying facts |
| Effect within the period | Specified fees may not be charged | Does not automatically guarantee insurance continuation | Clause 8.1.3 could be problematic even within free time |
| Effect of exceeding the period | Demurrage or Detention fees may arise | Exceeding alone does not necessarily terminate insurance | Confirm reasons for exceeding and arrangements for continued transit |
| Required documents | Shipping line tariff, Arrival Notice, gate-out and return records | Insurance policy, applicable clauses, storage instructions, delivery plans | Keep documentation clearly separated and organized |
Detention at CY or Bonded Warehouse
CYs and bonded warehouses are facilities commonly used in the ordinary course of international logistics. However, the facility name alone cannot determine whether the cargo remains within the ordinary course of transit.
If cargo is temporarily detained for customs declaration, customs inspection, D/O processing, gate-out scheduling, or arranging delivery vehicles, it could be considered within the ordinary course of transit.
On the other hand, if cargo is detained for commercial reasons unrelated to transportation, such as the buyer being undecided, the importer adjusting inventory, or intentionally withholding pickup due to awaiting payment, the transition to storage becomes an issue.
It is important to confirm the actual reason for delaying pickup, not just formal factors such as whether customs clearance has been granted, a D/O issued, or the free time period remains.
Use of Containers for Storage Purposes
Clause 8.1.3 defines one of the termination points of insurance as the moment when the insured or their employees choose to use transport equipment or containers for storage purposes other than the ordinary course of transit.
This clause emphasizes not only whether the cargo has been unloaded from the container but also the purpose for which the container is being used.
For example, there is a significant distinction between temporarily holding a container for a short period while waiting for the next day’s delivery vehicle, and storing the cargo inside the container for several weeks until the sales destination is determined.
Under Clause 8.1.2, the termination of cover occurs upon completion of unloading at the designated warehouse or similar facility. In contrast, Clause 8.1.3 focuses on the point when the decision to use the transport equipment or container for storage purposes is made. Attention should be paid to this difference in timing.
Relationship with Warehouse to Warehouse
Warehouse to Warehouse is a general expression indicating that marine cargo insurance continues from the place of origin to the destination.
However, this does not mean that all warehouse storage is covered indefinitely. Under ICC 2009, the termination of cover in Clause 8 is set based on the assumption that the cargo remains in the ordinary course of transit.
Insurance termination becomes an issue not only when unloading at the warehouse of the final destination is completed, but also when another warehouse is chosen for storage, allocation, or distribution outside the ordinary course of transit, or when the container is used for storage purposes.
Therefore, the continuation of insurance cannot be determined solely based on the expression Warehouse to Warehouse.
Relationship between ICC(A), ICC(B), ICC(C), and Incoterms
ICC(A), ICC(B), and ICC(C) primarily differ in the scope of covered risks. However, the basic structure of Clause 8 and Clause 9, which address the ordinary course of transit and termination of insurance, is common among them.
In contrast, Incoterms are rules that allocate costs, risk transfer, transport arrangements, customs clearance obligations, and insurance procurement responsibilities between the seller and the buyer. Incoterms do not directly modify the termination of insurance under marine cargo insurance clauses.
| Item | Main Provisions | Relationship with ordinary course of transit | Practical Confirmation Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| ICC(A) | Broad coverage of risks with common exclusions | Confirm insurance period based on Clause 8 and Clause 9 | Insurance policy, ICC(A), special clauses |
| ICC(B) | Coverage mainly for enumerated risks | Even if the insurance period continues, separately confirm whether the cause of damage is a covered risk | Insurance policy, ICC(B), accident cause materials |
| ICC(C) | Coverage mainly for more limited enumerated risks than ICC(B) | Separate the period judgment under Clause 8 and Clause 9 from the covered risk determination | Insurance policy, ICC(C), accident report |
| Incoterms | Allocation of costs, risks, and arrangement obligations between seller and buyer | Does not directly determine insurance period but affects who arranges insurance and handles claims | Sales contract, invoice, Incoterms terms |
| B/L・Waybill | Transport contract, place of receipt, destination, carrier, etc. | Serves as evidence to confirm planned transportation route and destination | B/L, Waybill, Booking confirmation |
| Insurance policy | Insured party, insured transit, clauses, special conditions, insured amount | Contractually defines the starting point of the insurance period | Insurer, insurance agent, policyholder |
For example, even if the seller arranges insurance under a CIF contract, whether the cargo has deviated from the ordinary course of transit is determined based on the applicable insurance policy and ICC. The same applies if the buyer arranges insurance under an FOB contract.
Do Not Confuse Clause 8.3 with Delay Exemption
Clause 8.3 provides that insurance may continue under certain conditions even during delays, deviations, forced discharge, reloading, transshipment, and similar events beyond the insured’s control.
However, the continuation of the insurance period and coverage for damages caused by the delay itself are separate matters.
Under ICC 2009 Clause 4.5, even if a delay results from a covered peril, losses, damages, or expenses arising solely from the delay itself are generally excluded. Separate confirmation is required for expenses related to general average under Clause 2.
| Check Item | Issue of Insurance Period | Issue of Covered Cause | Practical Handling |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cargo delayed due to port congestion | Insurance period may continue under Clause 8.3 | Financial loss solely due to delayed arrival is usually not covered | Separate confirmation of delay cause and presence of physical damage is required |
| Cargo was water damaged during the delay | Confirm whether insurance period was in effect at time of incident | Confirm specific external accident that caused the water damage | Investigate incident date/time, storage condition, and cause of flooding |
| Reefer cargo deteriorated | Confirm whether insurance period continued during detention | Distinguish among delay, temperature variation, inherent defect, equipment failure, etc. | Check special clauses, temperature records, and power supply logs |
| Lost sales opportunities | Judgment does not change even if within insurance period | Market loss and delay damages differ from ordinary physical cargo damage | Separate claims under sales contracts from marine cargo insurance claims |
Relationship with Termination of Contract of Carriage
The official title of ICC 2009 Clause 9 is Termination of Contract of Carriage.
If the contract of carriage is terminated at a port or place other than the originally intended destination due to circumstances beyond the control of the insured, or if the transit ends for another reason before discharge as specified in Clause 8, the insurance generally terminates as well.
However, if the insured promptly notifies the insurer and requests continuation of coverage, the insurer may agree to extend coverage subject to any additional premium required.
If continuation is granted, coverage may extend until the cargo is sold or delivered at that location, or, absent a special agreement, until the earlier of 60 days after arrival at that location.
If the cargo is re-forwarded within that 60-day period, or within an extended period agreed by the insurer, to the original destination or another destination, the termination of insurance will then be determined in accordance with Clause 8.
Relationship with Held Covered
Held Covered is a practical approach to confirm continued coverage under the assumption of notifying the insurer, additional premiums, and changes to terms when there are changes from the original transportation conditions.
However, the mere presence of the term Held Covered does not mean that insurance automatically continues unconditionally after the cargo departs from the ordinary course of transit.
Under Clause 9, prompt notification and a request for continuation of coverage are important. Clause 10 requires the insured to notify the insurer without delay of any change in the destination, and to negotiate the applicable rates and conditions.
In cases of extended detention, unloading at an unscheduled port, termination of the transport contract, change of buyer, transshipment to a different destination, or use of the container for storage purposes, it is important to contact the insurer or insurance agent before any loss occurs.
Judgment Flow for ordinary course of transit
- Confirm the insured transit under the insurance contract
Verify the origin, destination, applicable ICC clause, and special clauses from the insurance policy, blanket open cover, or application details. - Confirm the current location and current transportation stage
Determine whether the cargo is on board the vessel, at a transshipment port, in CY, CFS, bonded warehouse, delivery vehicle, or at the delivery point. - Check the termination grounds under Clause 8.1
Confirm whether any of unloading at final warehouse, storage/distribution in separate warehouse, use of container for storage purposes, or passage of 60 days has occurred. - Confirm the purpose of the delay and decision-maker
Ascertain whether the delay is caused by port, customs, or shipping line circumstances, or if the insured or their employees chose storage for commercial purposes. - Verify the next transportation arrangement
Check if there is a concrete scheduled delivery date, vehicle, delivery location, transshipment vessel, or gate-out reservation. - Determine if Clause 8.3 applies
Confirm whether circumstances involve delay beyond the control of the insured, deviation, forced discharge, reloading, or transshipment. - Consult Clause 9 or Clause 10
In cases of termination of the transport contract, completion of the insured transit, or change of destination, verify the requirement for prompt notice and request for continuation of cover. - Separately confirm the insurance period and cause of loss
Check if exclusions such as delay, inherent vice, or inadequate packing apply even within the insurance period. - Record insurer’s response
Obtain written confirmation regarding additional premiums, changes in terms, continuation period of coverage, and necessary documentation.
Cases Commonly Problematic in Practice
| Case | Main Cause | Documents to Check | Key Judgment Point | Initial Response |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CY gate-out delayed due to customs inspection | Inspection and inquiry by customs | Declaration records, inspection notice, response history, earliest possible gate-out date | Whether the insured has proceeded with procedures reasonably and whether subsequent delivery arrangements exist | Record the inspection process and delivery schedule; confirm insurance clauses if delay is prolonged |
| Transshipment delayed due to port congestion | Terminal congestion, connecting vessel delay | Shipping line notification, transshipment schedule, transport status | Whether the transport contract continues and if circumstances under Clause 8.3 apply | Check alternative vessel options, cargo storage locations, and cargo condition |
| Cargo held in CY for a few days due to delivery appointment scheduling | Adjustment of the delivery date at the delivery destination | Delivery appointment, dispatch request, gate-out booking, emails | Whether a concrete delivery schedule exists and the hold can be considered short-term transport waiting | Document reasons for the delay and confirmed delivery date in writing |
| Container held until the delivery destination was determined | Undecided delivery destination, inventory adjustment | Instructions from sales department, hold request, inventory planning | High possibility that use constitutes storage for preservation purpose under Clause 8.1.3 | Confirm the decision date and immediately consult the insurer or insurance agent |
| Cargo distributed to multiple delivery destinations within a bonded warehouse | Distribution, allocation, inventory management | Warehouse instructions, picking records, inventory ledger, delivery plans | Whether the case falls under allocation or distribution in Clause 8.1.2 | Identify the cargo unloading completion time and distribution start date |
| Forwarded to another city due to buyer change | Change in sales contract and destination | Change instructions, new sales contract, delivery instructions, insurance notices | Whether there are sections not automatically extended by Clause 8.2 or Clause 10 | Notify the insurer before moving cargo after decision on change |
| Transport contract terminated at an unexpected port | Vessel accident, port closure, shipping line transport cancellation | Termination notice, arrival date, alternative transport estimate, insurance notification | Whether notification under Clause 9 was made and claim for coverage continuation requested | Contact insurer without delay and confirm terms for onward transport or local sale |
| Reefer cargo deteriorated during long-term delay | Delay, power outage, temperature deviation, cargo nature | Temperature records, power records, alarms, survey reports | Distinguish insurance period, external accidents, Delay exclusions, and inherent defects | Secure temperature data and promptly conduct survey and damage mitigation measures |
Comparison of Freight Forwarders’ Scope of Involvement
The Standard Five Classifications used in this article are not established legal or industry-wide categories but an analytical framework employed here to organize the scope of freight forwarders’ involvement.
| Standard Five Classifications | Expected Involvement | Matters to Confirm Regarding ordinary course of transit | Areas Not Automatically Covered | Practical Handling |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Simple Intermediary | Booking, communication, document exchange as intermediary | Whether delay information and shipping line notices were accurately conveyed to the cargo owner | Decisions on insurance payments, guarantees on cargo condition, overall transport management | Prompt cargo owner to confirm insurance upon recognizing long-term delays or schedule changes |
| Cargo Transportation Service Provider | Providing cargo transport services utilizing actual carriers | Whether the transport contract remains active and if alternative transportation has been arranged | Unlimited liability beyond contracts and clauses | Organize transport records, notifications to subcontractors, and incident segments |
| NVOCC / House B/L Issuer | Issuing House B/L, involved as contract carrier | Destination on House B/L, transport termination, presence of delivery continuation obligations | Final determination on marine cargo insurance coverage eligibility | Reconcile transport status between Master B/L and House B/L parties |
| Door-to-Door Single Contractor | Integrated responsibility from pickup to final delivery | Next steps including inland delivery, the final delivery destination, and continuation of subcontractor arrangements | Unlimited liability for all transit segments | Centralize segment records and verify consistency with insurance destination |
| Agent/Coordinator for Specific Operations | Specific operations such as gate-out bookings, inspection coordination, delivery scheduling | Matters delegated for confirmation and reporting deadlines | Undelegated tasks like storage management, inventory control, insurance arrangements | Clarify scope of instructions; report abnormalities to principal if recognized |
Contracting Carrier and Actual Carrier denote legal or contractual statuses and do not serve as alternative classifications replacing the Standard Five Classifications.
Furthermore, physical tasks such as storage, inspection, vanning, devanning, CFS in-gate, and inland delivery do not themselves constitute a sixth classification. Confirmation requires cross-referencing actual contracts, issued documents, delegation details, clauses, and the operational reality.
Example 1: Waiting for 5 Days at the CY After Customs Clearance Before Delivery Appointment
Consider a case where import cargo has been cleared by customs and a D/O has been issued, but the container remained at the CY because the acceptance date at the delivery destination was five days later.
In this case, simply being within free time is not sufficient grounds for continuing insurance coverage. However, if the delivery appointment, transportation vehicle, and gate-out date are specifically confirmed and the five-day wait represents a reasonable schedule adjustment to complete the final delivery, it may be considered within the ordinary course of transit.
The documents to be confirmed include the delivery appointment, transportation request, gate-out reservation, customs clearance date, D/O, and CY records. It is important that these documents consistently exist from before the incident occurred.
Conversely, if no delivery appointment exists and the container was kept at the CY until the sales destination was decided, the assessment could differ even if the waiting period is the same five days.
Example 2: Container Held for 3 Weeks Due to Undefined Sales Destination
Consider a case where the importer is unable to finalize the sales destination and, to avoid costs associated with moving stock into a warehouse, leaves the container on hold for three weeks.
In this situation, even if the cargo is planned to be moved in the future, it is possible that it is currently being used for inventory storage until the sales destination is decided, rather than for the purpose of continuing transit.
If it is recognized that the importer has chosen to use the container as a warehouse substitute, the termination of insurance under Clause 8.1.3 becomes a concern. Whether this occurs within the free time period or whether Demurrage or Detention charges have been incurred is not a decisive factor.
The candidate timing for termination of insurance may not be after the three weeks, but rather at the point when the choice to use the container for storage was made. It is necessary to review instructions from the sales department, emails, internal approval documents, and shipping cancellation records, and promptly consult with the insurance company or insurance agent.
Concrete Example 3: When the Contract of Carriage Is Terminated at an Unscheduled Port
Consider a situation where due to a vessel accident or port closure, the cargo is unloaded at a port other than the original destination, and the shipping line notifies the termination of the contract of carriage.
It is not appropriate to assume automatic continuation of insurance under Clause 8.3 solely because the cargo is temporarily held at an unscheduled port. When the contract of carriage itself has been terminated, Clause 9 needs to be checked.
The insured should verify the termination notice, date of arrival at the unscheduled port, condition of the cargo, local storage location, and whether alternative transport is possible, then promptly notify the insurer and request continuation of cover.
Even if the insurer agrees to continue cover, issues such as additional premium, continuation period, local sale, onward shipment destination, and storage conditions become relevant. It is crucial not to proceed with arranging alternative transportation alone, but to confirm the insurance terms in writing.
Documents to Check in Case of an Incident
| Document | Information to Confirm | Role in Decision-Making | Practical Points to Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Insurance Policy, Blanket Scheduled Insurance, Special Clauses | Insured party, insured transit, applicable conditions, endorsements | Starting point for judgments under the insurance contract | Confirm not only the policy but also the application details and amendment notices |
| B/L, Waybill, Booking Confirmation | Transport contract, origin, destination, carrier, planned route | Indicates the originally planned transportation | Verify discrepancies with the actual transportation route |
| Arrival Notice, Delivery Order (D/O) | Arrival information, cargo release procedures, possibility of gate-out | Reference for the timing when cargo became available for pickup | Issuance of D/O alone does not prove storage intent |
| Vessel Discharge, CY, and Equipment Interchange Receipt (EIR) Records | Date of vessel discharge, gate-out date, container location | Objective documents to confirm start date under Clause 8.1.4 and detention periods | Check times, time zones, and correction records |
| Customs Declaration, Customs Inquiry, Import Permit | Progress of customs procedures, inspections, administrative holds | Confirm whether detention was necessary due to transportation | Separately confirm reasons for delayed release after permit issuance |
| Delivery Instructions, Delivery Appointments, Vehicle Arrangements | Whether subsequent transportation was concretely planned | Key documents showing continuity of the ordinary course of transit | Do not rely solely on schedules created post-incident |
| Warehouse Instructions, Inventory Ledger, Distribution Records | Storage, commercial stock, start of allocation and distribution | Materials directly linked to judgments under Clause 8.1.2 | Cross-check warehouse label with actual work performed |
| Email, Internal Approval Documents, Sales Department Instructions | Who chose storage, when, and for what purpose | Documents to confirm the timing of selection under Clause 8.1.3 | Verify consistency between post-incident explanations and contemporaneous records |
| Temperature, Power Supply, Alarm Records | Management status and temperature deviations of reefer cargo | Objective evidence to confirm cause and timing of damage | Distinguish between set temperature and actual measured temperature |
| Notices to Insurer, Responses | Notification date, requests for cover continuation, additional conditions, additional premiums | Key documents for handling Clause 9 and Clause 10 | Retain written records in addition to verbal communications |
Approach When There Are Contradictions Among Documents
When contradictions arise among documents, do not simply prioritize one single document. Instead, organize the assessment in the following order.
- Scope under the Insurance Contract
Determine the contractual insured transit and conditions from the insurance policy, applicable ICC, special clauses, and endorsement approvals. - Objective Chronology
Confirm the cargo’s location and timing from records such as vessel discharge logs, CY records, EIR, customs records, warehouse in/out logs, and temperature records. - Purpose and Instructions at the Time
Verify from delivery instructions, storage instructions, sales department emails, and delivery bookings what the cargo’s intended purpose was before the loss occurred. - Post-accident Explanation
While accident reports and statements from related parties are important, confirm whether they are consistent with the objective pre-accident records.
For example, even if a D/O has been issued, if the importer had suspended cargo pickup due to an undecided sales destination, the existence of the D/O alone does not prove that the ordinary course of transit was continuing.
Conversely, even if internal emails mention "temporary storage," if concrete next-day delivery bookings, vehicle arrangements, and gate-out reservations exist, this may indicate that the cargo was in a short-term wait as part of the ongoing transit.
The priority of documents is not absolute. It should be determined comprehensively by considering creation timing, authorship, objectivity, and consistency before and after the accident.
Precautions for Reefer Cargo, Food, and Pharmaceuticals
With reefer cargo, food, pharmaceuticals, and chemicals, prolonged detention often directly causes damage, so it is necessary to simultaneously confirm both the ordinary course of transit and the condition of the cargo.
Even if the insurance period has continued, issues such as shortened expiration dates due to delay, quality deterioration, or decline in market value caused by mere arrival delays could fall under Delay exclusion.
Additionally, it is important to distinguish the cause of incidents related to natural deterioration inherent to the cargo, temperature setting errors, power supply interruptions, refrigeration unit failures, door openings, condensation, and the like.
Documents for verification include the following:
- Temperature records from data loggers
- Reefer container temperature settings
- Power supply on/off records
- Alarm history
- Pre-Trip Inspection (PTI) records
- Storage records at CY or warehouse
- Door opening and closing logs
- Survey reports
- Manufacturing date, expiry date, allowable temperature range
- Special Clauses concerning risks of temperature variation
If temperature deviation or quality abnormalities are identified, it is crucial to contact the insurance company or insurance agent before disposing, selling, or processing the cargo, and to carry out surveys and damage mitigation measures.
Common Misunderstandings
| Misunderstanding | Actual Concept | Practical Points to Confirm |
|---|---|---|
| If it is within free time, marine cargo insurance coverage continues | Free time is a shipping line's charge system and does not directly determine the insurance period | Confirm the purpose of storage, the next scheduled transport, and termination causes under Clause 8 |
| If the cargo is inside the container, it is always considered in transit | If the container is used as a warehouse substitute, Clause 8.1.3 termination may apply | Check who decided and when the storage-use purpose was established |
| If the cargo is in the CY, it is under the shipping line’s control and thus covered | It is important not only who manages but whether the cargo is in the ordinary course of transit | Confirm the earliest movable date, reasons for pickup delay, and delivery plan |
| Warehouse to Warehouse coverage guarantees all warehouse storage | Storage, allocation, or distribution outside the ordinary course of transit may constitute termination of insurance | Verify the purpose of warehouse in-gate and the timing of unloading completion |
| Coverage always continues for 60 days after vessel discharge | If termination causes under Clause 8.1.1 to 8.1.3 occur earlier, those take precedence | Confirm not only the 60 days but also other possible termination causes beforehand |
| If insurance continues during delay, delay damage is also covered | Continuation of insurance and delay exclusions are separate issues | Check the specific physical damage cause and applicable exclusions |
| If the Delivery Order (D/O) is issued, the cargo remains in the ordinary course of transit | D/O is documentation for delivery procedures and does not determine storage purpose | Confirm reasons for stopping pickup after D/O issuance |
| If there is a plan to deliver later, the cargo is still considered in transit | Specific current transport arrangements, not just abstract future plans, are necessary | Check delivery date, vehicle, delivery destination, and gate-out reservations |
| ICC(A) means the insurance period is unlimitedly wide | Even ICC(A) is subject to Clause 8 termination and applicable exclusions | Separate confirmation of risk coverage scope and insurance period is required |
| If Incoterms is CIF, insurance always continues to destination | Incoterms and insurance contract termination are governed separately | Verify the actual policy, applicable ICC, and special clauses |
| It is sufficient to notify the insurer after an accident occurs | Clauses 9 and 10 require prompt notice once a change of circumstances is recognized | Consult as soon as stoppage of transport, change of destination, or long-term storage is identified |
Checklist for Decision-Making
| Verification Timing | Party to Confirm With | Items to Confirm | Actions if Issues Arise |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upon Arrival at Import Location | Importer, freight forwarder, customs broker | Final destination, delivery location, customs clearance plan, delivery schedule | If delivery location is undecided, verify that there is no transfer to storage or inventory purposes |
| During CY or CFS Detention | Shipping line, terminal, freight forwarder | Reason for detention, earliest possible gate-out date, next transportation arrangements | If prolonged, consult with the insurer or insurance agent |
| Upon Bonded Warehouse In-Gate | Importer, customs broker, warehouse operator | Purpose of in-gate, devanning time, inventory registration, presence of distribution | If for sales inventory or distribution purposes, confirm Clause 8.1.2 |
| When Utilizing Free Time | Importer, freight forwarder, delivery location | Whether preparing for regular gate-out or retention to save storage fees | If storage is a possibility, confirm termination of insurance |
| When Container is Retained | Importer, delivery operator, delivery location | Reason for retention, planned duration, delivery date, any use for storage purposes | If Clause 8.1.3 may apply, record the determination timing and notify the insurer |
| When Buyer or Destination is Changed | Seller, buyer, freight forwarder, insurance agent | Date of decision to change, new destination, transfer start date, insured transit section | Before moving the cargo, confirm the conditions under Clause 8.2 and Clause 10 |
| When Transportation Contract is Terminated | Shipping line, NVOCC, insurer, insurance agent | Termination location, arrival date, local storage, onward transport or sale plan | Issue prompt notice without delay and request continued coverage based on Clause 9 |
| During Reefer Cargo Detention | CY, warehouse operator, shipping line, surveyor | Power supply, set temperature, actual temperature, alarms, cargo condition | In case of temperature deviation, preserve evidence and conduct survey plus damage mitigation measures |
| When an Accident Occurs | Insurer, insurance agent, freight forwarder, involved parties | Location at time of accident, storage purpose, transportation plan, cause of damage | Separate insurance period and cause of coverage, submit chronological documentation |
Precautions in Freight Forwarder Practice
A freight forwarder is not in a position to independently determine the payment eligibility of insurance claims.
However, when recognizing situations such as prolonged detention, delivery postponement, Buyer changes, unloading at an unscheduled port, termination of the shipping contract, or use of containers for storage purposes, it is important to encourage the cargo owner or importer to confirm their marine cargo insurance coverage.
In particular, the following matters should be recorded:
- Date and time when the abnormality or change was first identified
- Reason for detention or storage
- Who decided on the storage, postponement, or re-forwarding
- Original and revised destination
- Whether subsequent transportation arrangements have been made
- Date and time of notification to the insurer or insurance agent
- Additional conditions indicated by the insurer
- Evidence of claims against the shipping line, warehouse operator, or other parties involved
It is important not to explain insurance continuity solely based on formal information such as "still at CY," "still inside the container," or "still within free time."
Summary
The ordinary course of transit is a concept used to determine whether cargo is within the normal flow of transportation as planned under the insurance contract, rather than whether the cargo is physically moving.
Temporary delays due to customs clearance, transshipment, port congestion, or waiting for delivery vehicles may still be considered within the ordinary course of transit. However, if the cargo is held for sales waiting, commercial inventory, distribution, allocation, exhibition, long-term storage, or if the container is used as a warehouse, the termination of insurance under Clause 8.1.2 or Clause 8.1.3 becomes relevant.
The 60-day rule after vessel discharge is not an unconditional guarantee period for coverage. If unloading at the final warehouse, storage outside the ordinary course of transit, or container storage use occurs earlier, that timing may represent the termination of insurance.
Also, even if the insurance period continues during a delay under Clause 8.3, damage caused solely by the delay itself is subject to exemption under Clause 4.5. It is necessary to distinguish between the insurance period and the cause of loss when confirming coverage.
In cases of contract termination, change of destination, or detention at an unexpected port, it is important to review Clause 9 or Clause 10 and contact the insurer or insurance agent promptly without waiting for an incident to occur.
The specific insurance period, continuation of coverage, additional premiums, and payment of claims depend on the actual insurance policy, applicable clauses, special clauses, cause of loss, and individual factual circumstances. If in doubt, consult the insurer or insurance agent before moving, selling, disposing of, or distributing the cargo.
This article aims to organize general practices in marine cargo insurance and does not guarantee coverage or claim payment under any individual contract.
