Termination of Contract of Carriage: What Happens to Cargo Insurance Coverage?
What Is Termination of Contract of Carriage?
Termination of Contract of Carriage refers to the concept of determining when marine cargo insurance coverage ends and under what conditions it may continue if the contract of carriage is terminated at a port or place other than the originally intended destination specified in the insurance contract.
In ICC 2009, Termination of Contract of Carriage is prescribed in Clause 9.
In international transport, the cargo may not reach the originally intended destination due to events such as port closures, vessel accidents, sanctions regulations, cancellation of shipping line operations, failed connections with feeder vessels, forced unloading, carrier bankruptcy, or inability to transport, resulting in the termination of carriage at an intermediate port or place.
In such cases, even if the cargo has not arrived at the final destination for the cargo owner, the original contract of carriage may be considered terminated, which could lead to the cargo insurance terminating in accordance with Clause 9.
However, when termination of the contract of carriage is due to circumstances beyond the control of the insured, and if the insured promptly notifies the insurer and requests continuation of insurance, coverage may continue for a certain period subject to additional premiums as necessary.
The critical point is not to assume that insurance continues simply because the cargo has not arrived at the destination, but to confirm whether the contract of carriage continues or has been terminated, and whether notification and continuation requests based on Clause 9 have been made.
Scope Covered in This Article
| Item | Contents Covered in This Article | Contents to Verify Separately |
|---|---|---|
| Termination of Contract of Carriage | Termination and continuation of insurance when the contract of carriage is terminated at a location other than the intended destination | Individual insurance policies, special clauses, additional premiums |
| ICC 2009 Clause 9 | Prompt notification, continuation request, 60-day standard, sale/delivery, onward carriage | Individual conditions presented by the insurer |
| Transit Clause | Ordinary course of transit and termination of insurance under Clause 8 | Final warehouse, storage purpose, distribution/allocation, final discharge port |
| Clause 8.3 | Insurance continuation during delay, deviation, forced discharge, reshipment, transshipment | Whether the contract of carriage continues or shifts to Clause 9 |
| Change of Voyage | Difference from change of destination under Clause 10 | Instruction issuer, new destination, agreement on rates and conditions |
| Held Covered | Practical approach to maintain coverage through notification and continuation request | Clause 9 text, notification timing, additional premiums |
| Forwarding Charges | Additional costs for unloading, storage, and onward carriage under Clause 12 | Causation with insured risks, exclusions, reasonableness of costs |
| 60-Day Standard | Different 60-day standards in Clause 8.1.4 and Clause 9.1 | Date unloading completed at final discharge port, date of arrival at termination location |
| Freight Forwarder Involvement | Shipping line notifications, cargo location, onward carriage, insurance notifications, support for evidence preservation | Insurance payment decision, carrier liability, determination of legal responsibility |
This article primarily focuses on the marine cargo insurance period at the termination of the contract of carriage. Claims for damages against the carrier, warehouse operator liability, specific additional premiums, and application of individual special clauses should be confirmed separately.
Clause Structure of ICC 2009
| Clause | Main Content | Relation to Termination | Practical Confirmation Points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clause 8.1 | Commencement of insurance, ordinary course of transit, normal termination of insurance | Defines the basic insurance period before termination under Clause 9 | Confirm final warehouse, storage purpose, completion of unloading, and passage of 60 days |
| Clause 8.2 | When cargo is moved from the final discharge port to a different destination | Insurance under the original policy may end when movement to the alternate destination begins | Confirm the point when the cargo is first moved toward the new destination |
| Clause 8.3 | Delays beyond control, deviation, forced discharge, reshipment, transshipment | Insurance may continue as long as the contract of carriage remains effective | Confirm whether there has been a transition to contract termination under Clause 9 |
| Clause 9 | Insurance termination and continuation request upon termination of contract of carriage | Main clause addressed in this article | Confirm the termination timing, notification date, continuation request, and additional premiums |
| Clause 10 | Change of destination after commencement of risk | Deals with a change to a new destination rather than termination of contract of carriage | Confirm who made the change, notification, and agreement on rate and terms |
| Clause 12 | Forwarding charges when transit is interrupted by insured risks | Concerns unloading, storage, and forwarding costs after termination | Confirm if cause is an insured risk and whether costs are reasonable |
| Clause 16 | Loss prevention, mitigation, and preservation of rights against third parties | Related to handling after termination and subrogation claims | Confirm notification deadlines and evidence for carriers and warehouse operators |
Termination of Contract of Carriage
Termination of contract of carriage refers to a situation where the contract to transport cargo to the originally intended port of destination ends at an intermediate port or place.
For example, if cargo destined for Tokyo is discharged at an intermediate port, and the shipping line notifies that "no further carriage will be provided, so please arrange collection of the cargo at this port," this would constitute such a case.
The mere fact that the cargo is unloaded at an unscheduled port does not automatically mean termination of the contract of carriage.
If the shipping line arranges transshipment onto another vessel and maintains responsibility for carriage to the original destination, this would likely be considered Forced Discharge, Reshipment, or Transhipment under Clause 8.3, whereby the ordinary course of transit continues.
On the other hand, if the shipping line terminates its obligation for further carriage, and the cargo owner must arrange a new contract of carriage, then Clause 9 on Termination of Contract of Carriage becomes relevant.
Reasons Why Insurance Also Generally Terminates
According to ICC 2009 Clause 9, if the contract of carriage terminates at a port or place other than the intended destination due to circumstances beyond the insured's control, or if the transit ends before discharge as set forth in Clause 8, marine cargo insurance generally also terminates.
From an insurance technical perspective, marine cargo insurance is underwritten based on specific agreed terms concerning the place of origin, destination, route, mode of transport, and expected ordinary transit period.
If the contract of carriage ends prematurely, the risks associated with the transit shift from the originally intended transport risks to different risks such as long-term storage at an unintended port, cargo handling, theft, temperature control issues, or transshipment by another carrier.
Even if the cargo physically exists, since it deviates from the originally contemplated ordinary course of transit, the location, duration, responsible party, storage methods, and transport plan all change, making unconditional continuation of insurance coverage inappropriate.
Therefore, Clause 9 establishes the principle of automatic termination of insurance upon such events but allows for continuation of coverage under revised conditions, including additional premium, if notice is given without delay and a request for continuation is made.
Differences between Clause 8.3 and Clause 9
| Item to Confirm | Clause 8.3 | Clause 9 | Practical Divergence Point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carriage Contract | In principle, the contract continues | Terminated at a place other than the scheduled destination | Whether the carrier maintains obligations to the original destination |
| Typical Situations | Delay, deviation, forced unloading, reloading, transshipment | Goods are requested for pickup at an intermediate port, and no further carriage occurs | Whether it is a temporary transport disruption or contract termination |
| Insurance Basis | Continues under Clause 8 and Clause 9 | In principle, terminates without notice and request to continue | Confirm the starting point of Clause 9 application |
| New Arrangements | Carrier often arranges reloading and onward carriage | Cargo owner may need to arrange a new onward contract | Existence of a new booking or carriage contract |
| Notification | Early notification is desirable for significant changes | Timely notification and request for continuation become important | Record the date when contract termination was recognized |
| Additional Premium | Does not necessarily arise solely from Clause 8.3 | Required if demanded by the insurer | Confirm continuation conditions in writing |
Difference from Change of Voyage
Change of Voyage is stipulated in ICC 2009 Clause 10.
Clause 10.1 requires the insured to promptly notify the insurer when changing the destination after the commencement of insurance, and to agree on the applicable premium rate and insurance conditions.
Termination of contract of carriage involves the early termination of the original carriage contract. In contrast, Change of Voyage refers to a change in the voyage purpose where the cargo is redirected to a new destination.
| Category | Termination of Contract of Carriage | Change of Voyage | Points to Confirm |
|---|---|---|---|
| Governing Clause | Clause 9 | Clause 10 | Do not confuse the applicable clauses |
| Core Fact | Original carriage contract terminated prematurely | Destination changed | Whether it is contract termination or destination change |
| Cause | Circumstances beyond the control of the insured | Under Clause 10.1, destination change by the insured | Who decided the change or termination |
| Action after Notification | Request continuation of insurance | Agree on premium and terms | Separate notifications to the insurer |
| Insurance Period | According to Clause 9.1 or 9.2 | Confirm conditions applicable to the new destination | Confirm before starting new transport |
Clause 10.2 provides that even if the vessel sails for a different destination without the knowledge of the insured or their employees, the insurance is considered to have commenced at the original start of transport.
Differences from Forced Discharge, Deviation, and Transhipment
| Category | Meaning | Typical Example | Insurance Issues | Points to Confirm |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Termination of Contract of Carriage | The original contract of carriage ends prematurely | Pickup is requested at an intermediate port and no further carriage is performed | Termination of cover under Clause 9 and request for continuation | Whether the carrier’s obligation to transport has ended |
| Forced Discharge | Unavoidable unloading at an unscheduled port or location | Unloading at an intermediate port due to vessel accident or port closure | Continuation of cover under Clause 8.3 and transition to Clause 9 | Whether the contract of carriage continues after unloading |
| Deviation | Departure from scheduled route | Calling at an alternate port for safety reasons | Continuation under Clause 8.3 and its relation to delay exclusions | Whether within the carrier’s discretionary authority |
| Reshipment | Reloading cargo onto vessel or transport again | Re-shipping onto another vessel after unscheduled unloading | Whether it continues as part of the ordinary course of transit | Date of reloading, carrier, and destination |
| Transhipment | Unloading and switching to another vessel or mode of transport during transit | Transferring cargo to a connecting vessel at a transshipment port | Continuation of cover under Clause 8.3 | Scheduled transfer, connecting service, and layover period |
| Delay | Slowing of the progress of carriage | Delay of connecting service due to port congestion | Insurance period may continue but delay damages may be separately excluded | Distinction between insurance period and cause of damage |
Notification and Request for Continuation of Insurance
Clause 9 states that the insurance will generally terminate upon the termination of the contract of carriage; however, if the insurer is notified without delay and a request for continuation of coverage is made, the insurance may continue under certain conditions.
According to the wording of Clause 9, the critical point is not merely to report an incident, but to notify the insurer of the fact that the contract of carriage has been terminated and to request the continuation of insurance.
The insurer may require additional premiums in line with changes in risk.
In practice, the following details are notified:
- Date and time when the termination of the contract of carriage was recognized
- Carrier or B/L issuer to whom the termination was notified
- Current location of the cargo and its estimated time of arrival
- Unloading status, storage conditions, and cargo condition
- Planned transshipment to the original destination
- Presence or absence of a new contract of carriage or booking
- Plans for sale, delivery, storage, or disposal
- Request for continuation of insurance
After notification, additional premiums, coverage terms, continuation period, applicable storage locations, and transshipment sections should be confirmed in writing.
However, it should not be uniformly treated that “no insurance exists until written approval from the insurer is received.” Rather, the focus should be on whether the requirements of prompt notification and request for continuation under Clause 9 are met.
Relationship with Held Covered
In practical operations, when changes occur that deviate from the contract terms, notifying the insurer and aiming to maintain coverage by assuming necessary additional premiums or changes to conditions is sometimes referred to as Held Covered.
However, the main text of ICC 2009 Clause 9 does not use the heading "Held Covered" but instead specifies concrete procedures involving prompt notification and a request for continuation of insurance.
Therefore, rather than assuming "Held Covered means automatic coverage," the following points should be confirmed:
| Confirmation Item | Details to Confirm | When It Could Be Problematic | Practical Response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Notification Timing | Was notification made without delay after recognizing termination? | Notification was delayed for a long period | Record the date and time of recognition and notification |
| Request for Continuation | Was a clear request for insurance continuation made? | Ended with only reporting the incident | Explicitly make a continuation request |
| Details of Risk | Were location, storage, transshipment, and duration explained? | Risk information is insufficient | Share cargo condition and planned handling |
| Additional Premium | Were additional premiums requested by the insurer confirmed? | Did not respond to additional conditions | Documentary confirmation of rates and payment terms |
| Change in Conditions | Were individual conditions attached to storage or transshipment segments? | Mistakenly assumed previous conditions continued unconditionally | Confirm the scope of continued coverage |
60-Day Standard in Clause 9
When notification and requests for insurance continuation are made under Clause 9, the insurance continues according to Clause 9.1 or Clause 9.2.
| Case | Handling under Clause 9 | Points to Confirm | Practical Response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cargo is sold and delivered at the termination point | Insurance terminates upon sale and delivery | Sale date, delivery date, buyer, receipt records | Notify the insurer before sale and delivery |
| Cargo reaches 60 days after arrival at termination point | Unless otherwise agreed, insurance terminates after 60 days | Exact arrival date/time, 60th day expiration date | Discuss continuation or extension before expiration |
| Transshipment to the original destination occurred within 60 days | Continues until termination under Clause 8 | Transshipment start date, carrier, route, destination | Confirm conditions before transshipment |
| Transshipment to a different destination occurred within 60 days | Follows Clause 8, but Change of Voyage and other confirmations are also needed | New destination, party requesting change, notification to insurer | Notify Clause 9 and Clause 10 matters separately |
| Extension beyond 60 days has been agreed | Follows the agreed extension period | Extension period, additional premium, applicable storage location | Confirm in writing, not orally |
| Within 60 days, cargo transferred to commercial inventory storage | Early termination under Clause 8.1.2 or 8.1.3 may apply | Storage purpose, distribution, allocation, inventory status | Confirm whether this is within the ordinary course of transit |
The 60 days in Clause 9 is not an unconditional grace period.
Based on timely notification and requests for continuation, termination is determined by sale/delivery, expiration of 60 days, or termination under Clause 8 after transshipment.
Difference between Clause 8.1.4 and Clause 9.1 regarding the 60-day period
| Comparison Item | Clause 8.1.4 | Clause 9.1 | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Applicable situation | When the cargo arrives at the intended final discharge port under ordinary transport | When the carriage contract is terminated at a place other than the scheduled destination | Distinguish ordinary transit from contract termination |
| Starting point | Upon completion of discharge from the ocean-going vessel | When the cargo arrives at the termination port or location | Do not confuse discharge completion with arrival |
| Notification and continuation request | Not a condition for starting Clause 8.1.4 itself | An essential condition for continuation under Clause 9 | Check notification history under Clause 9 |
| Early termination | Terminates earlier if reasons under Clauses 8.1.1 to 8.1.3 occur | Terminates earlier if sale or delivery occurs first | Do not manage the 60 days in isolation |
| Reforwarding | Confirm relationship with Clause 8.2 and others | After reforwarding within 60 days, follow Clause 8 | Record the new transit start date |
Both use the figure of 60 days, but the legal and contractual starting points and applicable situations differ.
Relationship with Forwarding Charges
If unloading, storage, or forwarding charges arise after termination of the contract of carriage, the Forwarding Charges under ICC 2009 Clause 12 may become an issue.
Clause 12 applies when, due to the action of an insured peril, the transit ends at a port or place other than the insured destination stated in the policy. It covers additional charges reasonably and properly incurred for unloading, storage, and forwarding to send the cargo on to the insured destination under the insurance.
| Comparison Item | Clause 9 | Clause 12 | Practical Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main Purpose | Defines the insurance period after contract termination | Handles additional charges after termination | Differentiates insurance period and cost coverage |
| Cause | Termination caused by circumstances beyond the insured’s control | Transit ended by the action of an insured peril | Clause 12 is not automatically triggered solely by Clause 9 application |
| Scope | Continuation of insurance on the cargo | Additional unloading, storage, and forwarding charges | Organize claimed charges individually |
| Reasonableness | Not central to the continuation condition but important in processing | Costs must be properly and reasonably incurred | Keep multiple estimates and reasons for processing |
| Exclusions | Subject to the overall insurance conditions | Subject to exclusions under Clauses 4, 5, 6, and 7 | Confirm causes and exclusion items |
| Issues on the Insured Side | Delays in notification and similar problems may arise | Costs arising from insured’s negligence, insolvency, or financial default are excluded | Separate cost causes accordingly |
Therefore, even if the contract of carriage is terminated and insurance continues under Clause 9, forwarding charges are not automatically covered under Clause 12.
Common Practical Issues
| Case | Main Issue | Documents to Check | Insurance Judgment Points | Initial Response |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The shipping line terminated carriage at an intermediate port | Termination of contract of carriage under Clause 9 | Shipping line notification, B/L, discharge records | Timing of termination and notification | Request continuation with insurer |
| After unloading at an unplanned port, a different vessel was arranged | Whether Clause 8.3 or Clause 9 applies | Transshipment notice, new booking, carrier notification | Whether original contract of carriage continues | Confirm the party responsible for carriage obligations |
| No connecting vessel resulted in long-term storage | Boundary between delay and termination of contract of carriage | Planned connection schedule, storage records, shipping line response | Whether this is mere delay or contract termination | Confirm intention to continue carriage in writing |
| Cargo was sold at the termination location | Sale/delivery under Clause 9.1 | Sale contract, delivery records, receipt | Time of insurance termination | Notify insurer before sale |
| 60 days after arrival at the termination location is approaching | Time period management under Clause 9.1 | Arrival records, notification records, onward transport schedule | Whether extension agreement or onward transport is arranged | Confirm in writing before expiration |
| Decided to forward cargo to a different destination | Clauses 9.2 and 10 | New destination instructions, new booking, quotation | Insurance period, premium rates, and conditions | Notify insurer before forwarding starts |
| Cargo was damaged while in storage | Insurance continuation at the time of accident | Accident date/time, storage records, continuation conditions | Whether within coverage period under Clause 9 | Conduct survey and notify accident |
| Claimed insurance for forwarding costs | Forwarding Charges under Clause 12 | Accident cause, quotation, invoice, forwarding records | Causal relation to insured peril | Consult insurer before incurring costs |
Comparison of Freight Forwarder Involvement Scope
The Standard Five Classifications in this article do not represent classifications established by law or the entire industry; rather, they are a framework used in this series to analyze the scope of freight forwarder involvement.
| Standard Five Classifications | Expected Involvement | Confirmation Points at Termination of Carriage | Scope Not Automatically Assumed | Practical Measures |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Simple Intermediary | Forwarding notifications from shipping lines, booking, documentation, communication intermediary | When the termination notice was received and when it was communicated to relevant parties | Final decisions on insurance continuation or carrier liability | Promptly forward notifications to cargo owners and insurance stakeholders |
| Cargo Transportation Service Provider | Transport service using actual carriers | Original transport contract, cargo location, party arranging continuation of carriage | Making guarantee judgments in place of insurers | Separate transport segments and additional charges |
| NVOCC / House B/L Issuer | Involvement in the transport contract as the House B/L issuer | Whether obligations continue to the destination listed on the House B/L | Automatic exemption solely based on Master Carrier’s decision | Confirm obligations separately for Master B/L and House B/L |
| Door-to-Door Single Contractor | Assuming overall responsibility from pickup to final delivery | All stages including continuation of carriage, storage, customs clearance, and inland delivery | Unlimited liability for all external factors | Manage responsibility parties and costs comprehensively by stage |
| Agent/Coordinator for Specific Operations | Coordinating individual tasks such as storage, continuation of carriage, and survey | Delegation details, approvers, cost limits, processing deadlines | Insurance decisions and legal judgments beyond delegation | Obtain written instructions before incurring costs |
Contracting Carrier and Actual Carrier are legal or contractual status concepts and do not replace the Standard Five Classifications presented here.
Example 1: When Cargo Retrieval is Requested at an Unexpected Port
Consider a case where cargo bound for Tokyo is discharged at Busan due to a shipping accident, and the shipping line notifies that "our carriage ends at Busan, so please arrange to pick up the cargo."
If the shipping line does not perform transshipment to Tokyo, this may constitute termination of the contract of carriage under Clause 9, rather than a simple forced discharge.
The cargo owner should immediately notify the insurer of the contract termination upon receiving the notice and request continuation of insurance coverage.
Subsequently, confirmation is needed regarding a new onward contract to Tokyo, storage conditions at Busan, additional premiums, and the applicability of forwarding charges under Clause 12.
Example 2: When the Same Carrier Continues Transport After Forced Discharge
Consider a case where cargo is unloaded at an unscheduled port due to port closure, but the shipping line arranges another vessel and retains transportation responsibility to the original destination.
In this situation, it is possible to treat it not as an immediate termination of the contract of carriage under Clause 9, but rather as a Forced Discharge, Reshipment, or Transhipment under Clause 8.3.
What needs to be confirmed is not only the fact that the cargo is at an unscheduled port, but also whether the original contract of carriage and the obligations of the B/L issuer continue.
If there is prolonged detention or a significant change in the transportation schedule, notification to the insurer should include the possibility of transition to Clause 9.
Example 3: Transshipment to Another Destination within 60 Days
Consider a case where the contract of carriage is terminated at an intermediate port, and the cargo owner decides to send the cargo to a buyer in another country within 60 days.
Under Clause 9.2, if the cargo is transshipped to the original destination or another agreed destination within the stipulated 60 days or an agreed extension period, the insurance may continue until the termination conditions of Clause 8.
However, when the insured changes the destination, Clause 10.1 also becomes relevant, requiring notification of the new destination to the insurer and negotiation of the applicable rate and terms.
It is important not to ambiguously handle insurance continuation under Clause 9 and destination change under Clause 10 with a single notification.
Documents to Verify in Case of an Incident
| Document | Information to Confirm | Practical Purpose | Points to Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| B/L and Waybill | Original destination, carrier, transport segment, contract terms | Confirm the initial transport obligations | Separate verification of House B/L and Master B/L |
| Booking Confirmation | Scheduled vessel, route, transshipment ports, destination | Verify the original transport plan | If differing from the B/L, check the circumstances |
| Official Notice from Shipping Line or NVOCC | Contract termination, unscheduled discharge, request for cargo collection | Determine the starting point for the application of Clause 9 | Record the date of notice and date of receipt separately |
| Vessel and Terminal Records | Dates and times of arrival, discharge, in-gate, and gate-out | Confirm arrival date and cargo location for Clause 9 | Preserve local time and time zone |
| Warehouse and Storage Records | Storage location, start date, cargo condition, manager | Check the accident timing and storage risks | Also confirm if treated as commercial stock |
| Transshipment Booking and New Transport Contract | New carrier, destination, start date, route | Verify Clause 9.2 and Clause 10 | Confirm the switching point from the original transport contract |
| Notification Records to Insurer | Notification date/time, continuation requests, information provided | Confirm procedures under Clause 9 | Keep records by email in addition to phone contacts |
| Additional Insurance Premium and Continuation Conditions | Covered period, location, transport segment, conditions | Confirm the coverage scope after contract termination | Do not rely solely on verbal explanations |
| Incident Photos and Survey Reports | Date/time of damage, cause, cargo condition | Basis for insurance claims and subrogation | Cross-check with the insurance period at the time of incident |
| Notifications to Carrier and Warehouse Operator | Notification to third parties about the incident and rights preservation | Preserve subrogation rights related to Clause 16 | Check contractually stipulated notification deadlines |
Order of Judgment When Documents Contradict
When notifications from the shipping line, B/L, terminal records, and cargo location records do not align, do not uniformly prioritize one single document for all facts. Instead, assign evidentiary roles on a case-by-case basis depending on the matter to be confirmed.
| Item to Confirm | Preferred Documents for Confirmation | Supplementary Documents | Points to Consider in Judgment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original Carriage Contract | B/L, Waybill, Carriage Terms | Booking Confirmation, Freight Contract | Confirm contractual destination and principal carrier |
| Expression of Intent to Terminate Carriage Contract | Official notification from carrier or B/L issuer | Email, Local agent report | Confirm whether the notifier has authority to terminate the contract |
| Physical Location of the Cargo | Terminal, warehouse, gate, unloading records | Shipping line tracking screen, local agent report | Prioritize objective, time-stamped records |
| Date of Arrival at Termination Point | Vessel arrival, unloading, terminal in-gate records | Arrival Notice, warehouse records | Identify the arrival event that triggers Clause 9 counting |
| Continuation of Original Carriage Obligation | Official response from B/L issuer, new carriage instructions | Transshipment plans, connecting booking | Do not conclude contract termination solely from physical detention |
| Start of New Transshipment | New booking, carriage contract, gate-out records | Freight invoice, transport instructions | Confirm the first movement indicating subsequent transport |
Objective, time-stamped records created at the time of the incident take precedence over later-prepared statements or memory-based oral explanations.
However, it is crucial to distinguish between the physical fact of where the cargo was located and the legal or contractual fact whether the carrier’s contractual carriage obligation has ended. Do not determine contract termination solely based on terminal records, nor judge actual cargo location based only on shipping line notifications.
Common Misconceptions
| Misconception | Actual Understanding | Practical Response |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance continues because the cargo has not yet arrived at the destination | If the contract of carriage terminates prematurely, insurance may also end under Clause 9 | Confirm the continuation of the contract of carriage |
| If the cargo is unloaded at an unscheduled port, it is always Clause 9 | If the contract of carriage continues, it may fall under Clause 8.3 | Confirm the carrier’s transshipment obligations |
| Insurance does not continue under Clause 9 without the insurer’s approval | Timely notification and a request for continuation are the core requirements; additional premiums may be required | Record the continuation request and confirmation of conditions |
| Coverage is unconditional for 60 days | Clause 9’s notification and continuation request are prerequisites; termination may occur early due to sale, delivery, etc. | Manage the arrival date and reason for termination |
| The 60 days in Clause 8.1.4 and Clause 9.1 are the same | The applicable situations and start points differ | Differ between the date of unloading completion and the date of arrival at the termination point |
| Change of Voyage and termination of the contract of carriage are the same | Clause 10 covers changes of destination; Clause 9 covers contract termination | Confirm whether it is a change or termination |
| If insurance continues, all transshipment costs are fully covered | Costs are judged under separate conditions such as Clause 12 | Distinguish between the insurance period and cost coverage |
| Since the cargo is stored by the shipping line, it is in the ordinary course of transit | Confirm not only the custodian but also the purpose of storage and the contract of carriage | Confirm reasons for storage and plans for continuation of transit |
| Arranging new transshipment automatically continues the original insurance | Confirmation under Clause 9.2, Clause 8, and Clause 10 is necessary | Notify the insurer before starting the new transshipment |
| If there is a discrepancy between shipping line notification and location records, prioritize the shipping line notification | Documents serve different roles for contractual facts and physical facts | Cross-check objective records for each confirmation item |
Decision Checklist
| Confirmation Timing | Counterparty | Points to Confirm | Actions if Issues Arise |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upon Receiving Shipping Line Notice | Shipping line, NVOCC, B/L issuer | Whether the carriage contract is terminated or if it is a temporary delay or discharge | Obtain formal notice and contractual explanation |
| When Cargo is Held | Terminal, warehouse, local agent | Location, arrival date, discharge date, storage condition | Keep records with timestamps |
| When Confirming Carriage Obligation | B/L issuer, carrier | Whether the obligation to original destination continues | Request written response |
| Upon Insurance Notification | Insurance company, insurance agent | Clause 9 notification and continuation request | Notify promptly upon recognition of termination |
| When Confirming Continuation Conditions | Insurance company, insurance agent | Additional premium, storage location, period, onward carriage section | Confirm conditions in writing |
| At 60-Day Management | Warehouse, local agent, cargo owner | Termination location arrival date, sale/delivery, expiry date | Discuss extension or onward carriage before expiry |
| When Considering Alternate Destination | Cargo owner, insurer, freight forwarder | Application of Clause 9.2 and Clause 10 | Notify new destination and conditions |
| Before Incurring Onward Carriage Costs | Insurance company, carrier, warehouse operator | Clause 12, necessity and reasonableness of costs | Share estimates and handling proposals |
| Upon Accident Occurrence | Insurance company, surveyor, custodian | Accident date/time, insurance continuation period, management section | Conduct survey and accident notification |
| When Considering Claims | Carrier, warehouse operator, insurance company, lawyer | Responsible party, notification deadlines, evidence | Preserve rights against third parties |
| When Documents Conflict | Carrier, terminal, warehouse, local agent | Separate confirmation of contractual facts and physical facts | Cross-check objective records with timestamps |
Points to Note in Freight Forwarder Practice
When a freight forwarder receives notice of unscheduled unloading, termination of carriage, inability to connect, or cargo pickup at an alternative port, it is important not to treat this merely as a schedule change.
First, confirm whether the contract of carriage has actually been terminated or whether the original carrier still retains the obligation to transport the cargo to the originally intended destination.
Next, organize information on the cargo’s current location, expected arrival date and time, unloading date and time, storage location, cargo condition, and planned onward transport.
If there is a possibility that the contract of carriage has been terminated, encourage the cargo owner to promptly notify the insurance company or insurance agent and request continuation of insurance coverage.
The freight forwarder is not in a position to independently determine insurance continuation under Clause 9, cost compensation or carrier liability under Clause 12.
However, arranging shipping line notices, B/L, terminal records, storage records, new bookings, and insurance notifications in chronological order is important to assess the insurance period and responsibility relationships.
In the event of an accident, clarify whether the damage occurred before termination of carriage, during storage at the termination location, or during new onward transportation.
Also, confirm notification deadlines to carriers, warehouse operators, and other third parties under Clause 16 to preserve subrogation rights.
Summary
Termination of Contract of Carriage is a critical issue for determining the insurance period under marine cargo insurance when the carriage contract ends at a port or place other than the originally intended destination.
Clause 9 of ICC 2009 stipulates that if the carriage contract is terminated due to reasons beyond the control of the insured, the marine cargo insurance coverage also generally terminates.
However, if the insured promptly notifies the insurer and requests continuation of the insurance, the insurer may continue the coverage subject to any additional premium requirements according to Clause 9.1 or 9.2.
The 60-day period in Clause 9 starts from the arrival at the place of termination. This differs from the 60 days after completion of unloading from ocean-going vessels at the final port of discharge under Clause 8.1.4, as the applicable scenarios and calculation bases are distinct.
Deviation, Forced Discharge, Reshipment, and Transhipment may allow insurance continuation under Clause 8.3, but if the carriage contract subsequently terminates, the situation transitions to the issues governed by Clause 9.
Change of Voyage is governed separately by Clause 10, which addresses changes of destination after the start of insurance but does not involve termination of the carriage contract.
Expenses related to unloading, storage, and onward carriage after termination must be evaluated separately from Clause 9’s insurance period provisions, with attention to the forwarding charges conditions set out in Clause 12.
When there is a discrepancy between the shipping line’s notification and records of cargo location, it is necessary to distinguish between the contractual fact of termination and the physical cargo location, cross-checking the Bill of Lading, formal notifications, terminal records, warehouse records, and new bookings based on their purposes.
Once termination of the carriage contract is confirmed, it is essential to promptly verify the status of the carriage contract, cargo location, arrival date, plans for onward carriage, insurance notifications, additional premiums, expiry of the 60-day period, and the limitation period for subrogation against third parties.
Whether coverage continues, the obligation to pay additional premiums, terms of security, compensation of costs, and the insurability of claims will depend on the actual insurance policy, specific clauses, carriage contract terms, reasons for termination, and the individual factual circumstances.
